Saturday, February 7, 2009

Increased civilian oversight legislation brewing in Manitoba

In Manitoba, the Doer government is proposing changes to the Police Act which would provide for meaningful civilian oversight of police forces in cases involving death or serious bodily harm. One of the proposals is to create an Independent Investigation Unit, like the SIU in Ontario, which would handle these kinds of cases. The Unit would also investigate other allegations against the police where there is a public interest in having an independent investigation. Public consultations are scheduled to begin at the end of February on the proposed changes. For more information, see Police Act Consulations: Background and Issues; and, Police Act Consultations: Questionnaire.

Currently, incidents involving serious injury or death are handled in accordance with a 2004 protocol. Under this protocol, the police agency involved decides whether to investigate the incident or to call in an outside agency. That decision is made by the Chief of Police. The results of the investigation are then reviewed by an independent legal counsel appointed by Manitoba Justice to determine if criminal charges should be laid. The Provincial Police Act also has a regulation requiring a major police department not involved in the incident to review the completed investigation in cases involving a police shooting and injury or death. Finally, there is the Fatality Inquiries Act which requires an inquest whenever a person has died in police custody.

Civilian oversight for non-criminal conduct is the domain of the Law Enforcement Review Agency (LERA). To learn more about LERA, click here. Criminal conduct is investigated by the police through Police Professional Standards Units.

Posted by Professor Tanovich

Thursday, February 5, 2009

Reflections on Scadding Court Summit on Bill 103

In May of 2007, the Liberal government passed Bill 103: An Act to establish an Independent Police Review Director and create a new public complaints process by amending the Police Services Act. This introduced a much-needed overhaul of the complaints system that was previously instituted in 1997. It came on the heels of a report by former Chief Justice Patrick LeSage on the complaints process in Ontario.Very little is known about the new police complaints process and when exactly it is expected to be in effect. We do know that the system will be headed by Independent Police Review Director, Gerry McNeilly. On February 5, 2009, Mr. McNeilly attended Windsor Law to launch LEAP. The IPRD has wide-ranging decision making powers to develop regulations, policy, and procedural aspects of the system as well as the discretion to refuse complaints. Mr. McNeilly was also present at the summit.

In response to Bill 103, Scadding Court Community Centre and CEAPC, extended invitations to the three pillars to engage in constructive discussion focused on critically analyzing the new legislation. I attended as note-taker on behalf of LEAP for the sessions on accessibility, transparency, accountability, public education and support. The different pillars were integrated into small working groups to discuss their perspectives and make recommendations to improve the proposed system. An executive summary of the report is available here.

I was also given the opportunity to participate in the discussions taking place. Given my experiences, including as a member of Students Against Anti-Black Racism at the University of Windsor, I entered the conference with cynical views of the current state of our criminal justice system and the seemingly widening power imbalances between systemic powers and ordinary citizens. SAABR has been struggling vigorously to seek redress for several Black students implicated in incidents of alleged police brutality and racism at an on-campus party in mid-January 2008. The footage of one student’s arrest, Bright Kyereme, is available on You Tube. None of the individuals chose to file complaints with the police because there is little faith, trust, and confidence in the current police complaints system. Professor Tanovich discussed this lack of faith in a commentary in the Windsor Star. This fact was a consistently recurring theme at the summit in Toronto.

Community members from all over Ontario came together to share their narratives and experiences. Many expressed their frustrations with the government’s delay in overhauling the system and criticized the lack of civilian oversight with enforcing police accountability. Their concerns also voiced the risks that racialized communities face at the hands of the police. I feel that their perspective was the one that I benefited from most from. As the least developed and often ignored pillar, communities at risk for police misconduct are an essential component that require much consideration and attention in implementing a successful police complaints process. In essence, their suggestions on how to improve police-community relations and community policing activities and how to ensure community safety remain critical factors to maintain communities’ participation and interaction with the new system. What made the Summit so important was that these voices were heard by lawyers, government members, police officers, human rights agencies, and community leaders who have the capabilities and resources to take these views into consideration and implement some real change. And unless this actualizes, it remains easy to be cynical of the new system that’s on its way in.

This event was a remarkable learning experience. It truly demonstrated the importance of bringing together the three pillars of government, police, and communities to share meaningful dialogue on Ontario’s new police complaints system.

Posted by Lily Tekle, Student Director

Tuesday, February 3, 2009

NYPD accused of making false arrests of gay men at adult video stores

The LGBT community in New York is alleging that police are using a 1977 "nuisance abatement law" in an effort to shut down adult video stores and to criminalize sexual orientation. The abatement law permits the City to sue and close businesses where alleged "criminal activity is demonstrated." The allegations involve the police setting up customers in adult video stores and falsely arresting them for prostitution offences. The scheme is described in the Gotham Gazette article as follows:

"Police are allegedly using handsome young undercover cops to cruise middle-aged gay men, offering to go home with them for consensual sex. As they leave the store together, the cop offers to pay the man for the sex, confusing the victims who can't imagine why the younger man would make such a proposal. Then, as they walk out of the store, the victim, despite never having agreed to any exchange of money, is surrounded by undercover cops, handcuffed and charged with prostitution."

As Christine Quinn, former executive director of the Gay and Lesbian Anti-Violence Project, put it "It's not even entrapment. ... These are false arrests."

The targeting of the gay community in New York and elsewhere in the United States by police continues to be a serious problem as documented by Amnesty International in their report "Stonewalled: Police Abuse and Misconduct Against Lesbian, Gay and Transgender People in the U.S."

Posted by Professor Tanovich

Monday, February 2, 2009

Lawsuit filed against OPP officers who tasered a 14-year-old Aboriginal girl in her jail cell

The family of a 14-year-old Aboriginal girl, identified as Jane Doe, has filed a lawsuit against two OPP officers for tasering her in the leg while she was in her jail cell because, according to the lawsuit, she refused to stop chipping the paint off the wall. According to the lawsuit, she was at the OPP detachment following an arrest for drunk and disorderly conduct. The lawsuit claims that the incident was recorded on videotape. It also contains a statement from a doctor who reported observing twin burn marks on her thigh. In addition to damages, the family is seeking an order prohibiting the use of tasers on minors except in cases where life is at risk. According to the OPP, its professional-standards bureau conducted an investigation into the incident. It acknowledged that the girl was tasered. It also cleared the officers of any wrongdoing.

This summer, Michael Langan, a 17-year-old Aboriginal boy was tasered and killed in Winnipeg. He was a suspect in a theft. He is the youngest person to be killed by a Taser in Canada.

These and other cases has led to a call for a moratorium on the use of tasers on teenagers. See "Youth Moratorium" Globe and Mail (4 February 2009).

Using exclusionary rule to secure police compliance with Constitution debated

The Supreme Court of Canada will soon be releasing two important judgments on the scope of Canada's exclusionary rule. One case involves a gun (R. v. Grant), the other a large quantity of cocaine (R. v. Harrison). Some of the issues that the Court will have to struggle with are referred to by Frank Addario, President of the Ontario Criminal Lawyers Association and Justice Michael Moldaver of the Ontario Court of Appeal in their panel discussion summarized in the link above.

One of the problems in exclusionary discourse is the failure to factor in the disproportionate number of Aboriginal and racialized individuals who are subjected to unconstitutional police conduct on a daily basis. Exclusion serves as an important protection against racial profiling. The studies reveal that racialized individuals have less trust in the police complaints process and justice system than Whites and so other means of securing police compliance such as civil suits and police complaints are not likely going to materialize.

In the United States, the Supreme Court has also begun to narrow its exclusionary rule. The American context is different, however, because there is very little balancing that goes on once a breach has been found. In Canada, admission is the presumed position not exclusion. The mood of the U.S. Supreme Court is captured in an article in a recent New York Times. Click here to read it.

Posted by Professor Tanovich

Sunday, February 1, 2009

$20M Leone civil suit filed

On April 27, 2007, Carl Leone of Windsor, Ontario pleaded guilty to 15 counts of aggravated sexual assault for having unprotected sex with several women and not revealing he was HIV positive. Leone was sentenced to 18 years in prison. On January 29, 2009, two of his victims launched a $20 million lawsuit against Leone, the Windsor Police Services Board and the Windsor Essex County Health Unit. According to the Windsor Star, the lawsuit alleges that police failed to investigate Leone in a reasonable, diligent and timely manner and that they failed to warn the public when they became aware of his activities. For a discussion of the police duty to investigate a crime or complaint with due care, see Hill v. Hamilton-Wentworth (Regional Municipality) Police Services Board [2007] 3S.C.R. 129. The Hill case dealt with the duty owed to a suspect and although the Court recognized the duty they found there was no breach of the duty on the particular facts of this case. For a case which involves an action by a victim for the failure of the police to properly investigate a crime, see Mooney v. British Columbia (Attorney General)[2004] 10 W.W.R. 286 9B.C.C.A.). Again, although the Court recognized the existence of the duty, the action failed. The Court of Appeal held that there was a lack of proof of causation between the failure of the police to properly investigate and the subsequent commission of the crime. For a discussion of the police duty to warn potential victims see Jane Doe v. Metropolitan Toronto (Municipality) Commissioners of Police (1998), 160 D.L.R. (4th) 697 (Ont. Gen. Div.).  

Posted by Professor Wilson

Saturday, January 31, 2009

BCCA upholds damages for strip search of BC lawyer

On August 1, 2002, Vancouver police thought that Cameron Ward, a noted civil rights lawyer in British Columbia, matched the description of an individual they had been warned might try and throw a pie at Prime Minister Chretien during his speech at an outdoor dedication ceremony in Vancouver's Chinatown. Ward was arrested and detained for four hours and strip searched. The trial judge concluded that his arrest for breach of the peace was lawful because he had been protesting his detention and drawing attention to himself. However, the trial judge further held that his continued detention was unlawful and that the strip search by corrections officers employed by the City of Vancouver violated section 8 of the Charter. He awarded $5,000 in damages for the tort of unlawful imprisonment and $5,000 for the section 8 Charter violation. The Court of Appeal did not interfere with these findings or damages.

The decision is significant because a majority of the Court of Appeal rejected the City of Vancouver's argument that there should be no award of damages in civil cases where the Charter violation by government actors occurred absent a concurrent tort, abuse of power, negligence or wilful blindness.

Click here for the decision.

Posted by Professor Tanovich

Commission for Public Complaints Against the RCMP releases first major study of complaint review process

This week the Commission for Public Complaints Against the RCMP issued its first ever report on the RCMP public complaints process entitled Review of the RCMP's Public Complaint Records 2007. In 2007, 3,104 complaints were made against the RCMP with neglect of duty, improper attitude and improper use of force being the most common issues raised. Unfortunately, there is no specific category for racial profiling and so it is unclear how many complaints involved racial discrimination.

The Commission headed by Paul Kennedy, Chair, raised a number of concerns including an under-reporting of complaints in rural and remote areas and lack of awareness of the rights of complainants. In an effort to improve public trust, transparency and accountability, the Commission issued the following recommendations:

Recommendations

"Recognizing the importance of Force-wide consistency and based on the findings of the analyses within the Review of the Record Project, the Commission recommends the following:

1. That the Professional Standards and External Review Directorate at RCMP Headquarters organize a Force-wide meeting of divisional Professional Standards Units and the Commission in order to discuss best practices and ways of improving efficiency and effectiveness in the public complaint process.

2. That the Professional Standards and External Review Directorate at RCMP Headquarters send out a directive clearly articulating:
a. when it is appropriate to informally resolve improper use of force complaints and when it is not;
b. how public complaints defined under Part VII of the RCMP Act are to be processed when the complainant raises statutory offence allegations; and
c. when it is appropriate to terminate a public complaint under the RCMP Act and what information must be included in a Notice of Direction.

3. That the RCMP implement a more efficient means of tracking public complaints and that Divisions and detachments provide the Commission with a copy of all of the outstanding complaint dispositions.

4. That the RCMP ensure that those tasked with capturing public complaints and writing complaint dispositions be appropriately trained and that manuals related to the public complaint process be immediately updated to ensure a standardized national approach.

5. That the RCMP commit to improving its service standards by implementing ways to reduce wait times and increase processing times for complaint dispositions.

6. That the RCMP ensure that all of the complaint dispositions be provided to the Commission concurrent to being provided to the member and the complainant."

Posted by Professor Tanovich

Friday, January 30, 2009

"Policing gun crime without guns"

This is the title of a new article by Professors Tracey L. Meares of Yale University and Andrew Papachristos of the University of Massachusetts. In it, the authors "discuss the policy potential of a unique intervention effort that polices gun offenders with a hybrid mix of traditional enforcement and models of normative change." In particular, they examine the impact that Project Safe Neighborhoods (PSN), a billion-dollar federal program to promote new ways to reduce the number of gun-crimes, has had on the significant reduction of gun homicides in Chicago.

Posted by Professor Tanovich

Montreal municipal authorities considering "no police insult" by-law

Montreal police are urging municipal authorities to pass by-laws in March that would enable them to ticket and fine anyone who verbally insults them. The issue has draw concerns about freedom of expression from a number of activists and academics including Professor Dick Moon at Windsor Law.

In addition, there is a concern that vague laws like this will serve as a vehicle to promote racial harassment for two reasons. First, they provide the police with a pretext to conduct a criminal investigation. Indeed, a number of concerns have been expressed over the number of existing by-laws governing conduct known as "incivilities" and the disproportionate impact these laws are having on Black and Latino youth in Montreal. See the 2007 submissions of CRARR (Centre for Research Action on Race Relations) to the United Nations Committee on the Elimination of Racial Discrimination. Second, given the sensitivity of those in power when accused of racism, the police are more likely to use this power when confronted by insults from Aboriginal and racialized individuals than from Whites.

Posted by Professor Tanovich

Thursday, January 29, 2009

Two Vancouver police officers charged with assault and robbery in unprovoked attack of South Asian victim

Assault and robbery charges have now been laid against two Vancouver police officers following what the victim, Firoz Khan, described as a vicious and unprovoked attack during which racial slurs were made against him. Constable Jeffrey Klassen was charged with assault. Constable Griffin Gillian was charged with robbery. Klassen was a use of force teacher at the B.C. Justice Institute for four years. The officers were off-duty and Khan was delivering papers to the Hyatt Regency Hotel. A third officer present during the attack was not charged because the police believe that he tried to intervene. Two City of Vancouver workers witnessed the incident. According to an earlier newspaper report, the police will not be treating the case as a hate crime because Khan cannot identify which officer uttered the racial slurs.

The case is the latest in a number of incidents of serious violence and death involving police officers in British Columbia. See "B.C. Police Officers Under Scrutiny", Vancouver Sun (26/01/09).

Posted by Professor Tanovich

Wednesday, January 28, 2009

SIRC identifies concerns with Canada's spy agency's investigation of terrorism and reliance on information obtained by torture

The Security Intelligence Review Committee (SIRC) is a body created in 1984 and empowered under the Canadian Security Intelligence Service Act to review the actions of the Canadian Security Intelligence Service (CSIS), Canada's spy agency. It also investigates citizen complaints about CSIS. The SIRC review model was discussed recently by the Supreme Court of Canada in Charkaoui v. Canada (Citizenship and Immigration), [2007] 1 S.C.R. 350 at paras. 71-74.

In its 2007-2008 Annual Report, SIRC pointed to a number of problems with the investigation of suspected terrorist activity. In one instance, SIRC was critical of the failure of CSIS to include the relevant literature concerning whether a particular group was a terrorist organization in the "targeting approval process." In another investigation involving what CSIS calls "second-generation terrorists" or "homegrown" terrorists, CSIS had failed to obtain the proper approval before it sent a "human source" to obtain information within a sensitive institution (e.g. academic, political, media, religious or trade-union fields). There were also concerns raised about the investigation's target-approval documentation.

SIRC also recommended that CSIS adopt the recommendations made out of the Arar Inquiry as it relates to Canada's dealings with countries or agencies that use torture as a means of gathering information. As SIRC put it in their review:

Based on these facts, SIRC found CSIS is concerned with human rights, but nevertheless may use information obtained by torture. Although it did not find a “total lack of concern” for evidence obtained by torture, SIRC did find that CSIS focused on the impact that torture might have on the reliability of information used in carrying out its responsibilities under the CSIS Act, rather than on its obligations domestically under the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms and the Criminal Code of Canada, as well as internationally under the treaties signed by Canada that absolutely reject torture.

Posted by Professor Tanovich

Tuesday, January 27, 2009

LAPD rejects statistical evidence of racial profiling

In October of 2008, the ACLU of Southern California released a report entitled Racial Profiling & the LAPD: A Study of Racially Disparate Outcomes in the Los Angeles Police Department. The report examined 700,000 cases involving LAPD stops of pedestrians and drivers between July 2003 and June 2004. The study was conducted by Professor Ian Ayres, an economist and law professor at Yale Law School.

After controlling for violent and property crime rates in specific neighbourhoods and other relevant factors, Ayres found that Blacks and Latinos were far more likely to be stopped, frisked and searched than Whites. A critical finding of the study was that the disparity cannot be explained by differential crime rates. Blacks were 42% less likely to be in possession of a weapon after being frisked; 23% less likely to be in possession of drugs; and, 25% less likely to be in possession of other contraband than Whites. Latinos were 32% less likely to be in possession of a gun after being frisked; 34% less likely to be in possession of a gun; and, 12% less likely to be in possession of other contraband than Whites.

The report also found that over the last five years, the LAPD has received approximately 1,200 complaints alleging racial profiling. All 1,200 cases were found to be unsubstantiated.

Despite the findings, LAPD Chief William Bratton appeared before the civilian commission two weeks ago and disputed the accuracy of the data claiming that the LAPD does not engage in racial profiling. In a commentary, "The LAPD and Racial Profiling", published in the Los Angeles Times shortly after the release of the study, Professor Ayres defended his findings.

Posted by Professor Tanovich

SCC imposes disclosure obligation on Crown with respect to police misconduct files

In a landmark decision, the Supreme Court of Canada held, in R. v. McNeil, 2009 SCC 3, that police disciplinary records relevant to a criminal case must be disclosed by the Crown to the accused. Justice Charron, for the entire Court, defined relevance to include "where the misconduct is either related to the investigation, or the finding of misconduct could reasonably impact on the case against the accused." The case also confirms the constitutional obligation on the police to disclose to the Crown all material pertaining to the investigation of the accused. For more on the case, visit theCourt.ca.

For decisions requiring production of police discipline records in human rights cases involving allegations of racial and sexual orientation discrimination against the police see: King v. Toronto Police Services Board, [2008] HRTO 33; and, Nassiah v. Peel Regional Police Services Board (No.1), [2006] HRTO 18.

Posted by Professor Tanovich

Crown Attorney files racial profiling human rights complaint against Toronto police officers

A Toronto Crown Attorney with the "Guns and Gangs" project has filed a human rights complaint against the Toronto Police Service and a number of its officers. Roger Shallow alleges that he was unlawfully arrested and strip searched following a confrontation with two police officers in Toronto's Entertainment District. As he put it in his complaint, "the unspoken message to me was: lawyer, Crown, or whatever, you're still just a black guy so know your place boy." The charges of causing a disturbance and assault resist arrest against Shallow were withdrawn by an independent prosecutor brought in from London, Ontario. In an extraordinary move, the Toronto Police Association has filed a complaint with the Law Society of Upper Canada concerning the decision of Jeanine LeRoy, a London defence lawyer, to withdraw the charges. One of the officers involved in Shallow's arrest is currently facing possible dismissal from the force following her conviction for impaired driving.

There are a number of racial profiling complaints pending before the Ontario Human Rights Commission. In a 2007 decision (Nassiah v. Peel Regional Police Services Board), the Tribunal found that a Peel Regional police officer had engaged in a discriminatory investigation following a shoplifting complaint because Ms. Nassiah was Black. The Tribunal ordered Peel to pay Ms. Nassiah $20,000 and ordered the Service to take systemic steps to address racial profiling.

Posted by Professor Tanovich

Friday, January 23, 2009

Crown asks Ontario Court of Appeal for new trial for officer acquitted in assault of protester caught on video

It is rare for the Crown to appeal an acquittal involving a police officer. But that is exactly what the Crown has asked the Ontario Court of Appeal in a case involving assault and perjury. On Nov. 8, 2003, during a protest by the Ontario Coalition Against Poverty, a video-camera caught Officer Amar Singh Katoch punch Alex Levant, a PhD student at York University. The officer had testified at Levant's trial that it was Levant who had assaulted him. Once the video was shown in court to the officer, the charges against Levant were dropped and now Katoch was charged. Despite the videotape evidence, Katoch was acquitted at his trial.

Tuesday, January 20, 2009

Prof. Tanovich interviewed about LEAP

On January 20, 2009 Professor David Tanovich, Academic Director of LEAP, was interviewed on C-FAX 1070, Victoria by Murray Langdon on his afternoon drive talk show, Newsline PM. During the interview, Professor Tanovich discussed the origins and goals of Windsor Law's new student-led initiative, LEAP. Listen to the interview.

Monday, January 19, 2009

Second phase of Braidwood Inquiry into taser death of Robert Dziekanski under way

The second stage of the Braidwood Inquiry into the taser death of Robert Dziekanski at Vancouver International Airport on October 14, 2007 is now under way. This second stage involves providing the Dziekanski family with a complete record of what happened that day. The first stage involved hearings to enable the Commissioner, a former British Columbia Court of Appeal justice, to provide recommendations on the use of tasers by the police.

Posted by Professor Tanovich

LEAP is launched

The Law Enforcement Accountability Project (LEAP) has been launched at the University of Windsor Law School. Its launch attracted the attention of Kirk Makin, the Justice reporter for the Globe and Mail. Click here to read the article.

Mr. Gerry McNeilly, the Director of the Office of the Independent Police Review in Ontario will be the keynote speaker at the official LEAP launch at University of Windsor Law School on February 5, 2009. The launch will take place at 5:00 pm in the Law School's Moot Court.

Additionally, the Windsor Star released an article on LEAP which can be read here.

Saturday, January 17, 2009

Marijuana grow-op charges in Toronto thrown out because of racial profiling

In R. v. Nguyen (2009), Justice William Bassel of the Ontario Court of Justice threw out evidence obtained by the Toronto police because their search warrant was tainted by racialized stereotypes. According to a report of the case in the Toronto Star, the police targeted Mr. Nguyen following a tip from an anonymous source that "the front yard is looked after enough to avoid suspicion" and "two years ago Asian people bought the house." In finding a section 8 Charter breach, Justice Bassel observed "what possible relevance can the fact that the supposed owners are Asian have, other than to subtly mark this fact as an improper stereotypical message ... that here goes again yet another Asian grow operation?"

Nguyen is now the fourth recent case involving direct evidence of racial profiling. In R. v. Nguyen, [2006] O.J. No. 1221 (Ont. C.J.), the Information to Obtain a Search Warrant included a statement from a police officer that all of the marijuana grow operations he had investigated involved individuals of Asian descent. As the trial judge put it, "the information as presented, suggests that since all previous cases involved Asians, all Asians or Vietnamese are involved in this care, and, therefore, the home in question must contain a marijuana grow operation. This suggestion is erroneous and offensive." In R. v. Mac, [2005] O.J. No. 267 (S.C.J.), the Information to Obtain a Search Warrant included a statement from a police officer that "through my experience I have found that most of these operations are being run by East Asian organizations." And, finally, in R. v. Van Trong Nguyen, [2006] O.J. No. 272 (S.C.J.), the lead investigator attended the local registry office and searched for homes in Barrie, Ontario owned by individuals with Vietnamese names.

What makes these cases so troubling is that the officers admitted that they took into account the racialized background of the individual in their investigation. It reveals how stereotypes often become so normalized that they appear to be reasonable and cause us to fail to critically step back and think about the fallacious reasoning upon which the observation is grounded. The vast majority of marijuana is grown in Canada by Whites as they make up the majority of the population and the majority of users and traffickers. Consider, for example, that Corrections Canada reported that in 2004, 75% of drug offenders in federal institutions were White. Click here for the report. If the police focus all of their attention on one particular group, they will, because crime is widespread in all segments of our society, find some cases of criminality. But they will have done so at considerable cost. Their conduct will perpetuate stereotypes that will further marginalize already vulnerable groups. It will have subjected countless individuals to unwarranted harassment and psychological harm and it will waste valuable resources preventing the police from detecting even more illegal activity.

Another reason that police officers do not realize that their conduct is problematic is as a result of training and how racial profiling is defined by many police forces. Many police agencies use a definition of racial profiling set out by CALEA (Commission on Accreditation for Law Enforcement Agencies). CALEA Standard 1.2.9 prohibits profiling where race is the only factor used in the exercise of discretion. In fact, CALEA uses a Canadian case out of Brantford as part of their training materials. In that case, the officer admitted that one of the factors he took into consideration was that "the owners were of the same race as in similar, illegal grow house arrests." CALEA argues that the arrest was the result of good unbiased policing because other factors were taken into account including high electricity consumption and large heat loss. See Case Number 48.

Posted by Professor Tanovich