Showing posts with label Strip Searches. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Strip Searches. Show all posts

Monday, August 22, 2011

Windsor Police Service Strip Search Practice “Troubles” Court

Ten years ago the Supreme Court of Canada overturned the drug conviction of Ian Golden and set out constitutional limits and guidelines on the ability of the police to strip search suspects. Last week, Justice Renee Pomerance, of the Windsor Superior Court of Justice, heard “disturbing” evidence that Windsor Police are strip searching approximately 50 percent of those arrested on drug charges. However, no records are kept of the number of searches where no evidence is found and so it is hard to know the actual number and who is most likely to be searched and under what circumstances. This troubled Justice Pomerance as well as the fact that there is no prior authorization from a senior officer practice. 

In R. v. Golden, the Court confirmed that reasonable and probable grounds to arrest do not ipso facto confer automatic authority for the police to carry out a strip search. Further,
           
            99        In light of the serious infringement of privacy and personal dignity that is an inevitable consequence of a strip search, such searches are only constitutionally valid at common law where they are conducted as an incident to a lawful arrest for the purpose of discovering weapons in the detainee’s possession or evidence related to the reason for the arrest.  […] [P]olice must establish reasonable and probable grounds justifying the strip search in addition to reasonable and probable grounds justifying the arrest.  Where these preconditions to conducting a strip search incident to arrest are met, it is also necessary that the strip search be conducted in a manner that does not infringe s. 8 of the Charter.

114      Where the circumstances of a search require the seizure of material located in or near a body cavity, the individual being searched should be given the opportunity to remove the material himself or the advice and assistance of a trained medical professional should be sought to ensure that the material can be safely removed. In this case, the plastic wrap was located between the appellant’s buttocks. The police had no way of knowing whether it was physically lodged inside him in such a way that it could not be safely retrieved without medical intervention. Nevertheless, the arresting officers undertook to remove the package themselves, through physical coercion and forceful probing and tugging at the package, and by instructing the appellant to “let it out” and to “relax”. The risk this presented to the appellant’s health was made more acute by the fact that after the appellant accidentally defecated […]
116      We particularly disagree with the suggestion that an arrested person’s non-cooperation and resistance necessarily entitles police to engage in behaviour that disregards or compromises his or her physical and psychological integrity and safety.  If the general approach articulated in this case is not followed, such that the search is unreasonable, there is no requirement that anyone cooperate with the violation of his or her Charter rights.  Any application of force or violence must be both necessary and proportional in the specific circumstances.  In this case, the appellant’s refusal to relinquish the evidence does not justify or mitigate the fact that he was strip searched in a public place, and in a manner that showed considerable disregard for his dignity and his physical integrity, despite the absence of reasonable and probable grounds or exigent circumstances.
Justice Pomerance was presiding over the Charter application of Bart Muller to exclude evidence, including 39.5 grams of crack, 23.7 grams of cocaine and 12 oxycondone tablets hidden in his buttocks, from his trial for three counts of possession for the purpose of trafficking. 

While the court ultimately found the evidence against Muller admissible because the police had reasonable grounds to strip search – for example, they were acting on the tips of two informants, money and paraphernalia were found on or close to Muller, and he was evasive with police, Justice Pomerance observed that the officers’ failure to provide privacy and dignity was by "no means trivial”.  Contrary to the guidelines in Golden, Muller was entirely naked, in less than private conditions and not given the opportunity to voluntarily remove the baggie when strip searched at the police station.  

However, Muller was not the only individual strip searched as a result of the police investigation. After Windsor Police obtained a warrant to search the Detroit Street apartment Muller was said to be occupying, three men and a woman visiting the property were taken into custody and strip searched. All were released without charges after no evidence was found on their person. Yet, as defence counsel discovered after requesting disclosure, no record of the strip searches could be found. A Windsor police officer had permitted the police video to be destroyed.

Justice Pomerance noted that the illegal searches of these citizens and failure to keep records of the incidents was both “disturbing” and “unacceptable”. Moreover, it gives the appearance that a “disproportionate number of strip searches are being carried out by the Windsor Police Service”. Consequently, the court recommended that the Windsor Police Service revise its training procedures and strip search policy to conform to constitutional standards.

Windsor Mayor Eddie Francis indicated in an interview with The Windsor Star that he “take[s] the comments made by the court very seriously”, and that he and the Windsor Police Services Board “will raise those issues and ask for a response.”

Of course, Windsor is not the only jurisdiction with evidence or reports indicating that the number of strip searches by police is sharply increasing.  According to the Toronto Star, Toronto Police Service’s own statistics reveal that at least 60 percent of the 50,000 arrested in 2010 were strip searched, which represents a spike of 28 percent since 2001 where almost 21, 000 more arrests were made. Chief Bill Blair attributes the apparent influx to more detailed accounting of strip searches, and maintains that every situation is assessed on a case-by-case basis. Yet, the same statistics report that the Toronto police came up empty-handed in 70 percent of the strip searches performed in 2010.

Some, including John Sewell of the Toronto Police Accountability Coalition, intimate that the high percentage of searches and empty results suggests that “inherently humiliating and degrading” searches (Golden at paras. 89-90) are becoming routine and being done to “belittle” and “humiliate” people, not for investigative purposes. Sewell suggests that if police are trained to and spend more time conducting better pat down or frisk searches to see if someone is hiding something in his or her underwear, there would be less need to proceed to level three strip and cavity searches. The Toronto Police Services Board has asked Chief Blair to prepare a report on the force’s policies and practices on searches and how they could be improved.

The recent high profile cases of Stacy Bonds, Sean Salvati, and David McPhail have also called into question police accountability and suggested that strip searches are being used to humiliate and intimidate. In March, Ontario’s Special Investigations Unit charged Sergeant Steve Desjourdy with sexual assault in connection with the cellblock strip search of Stacy Bonds.

McPhail’s case made headlines in June when Justice June Maresca threw out breathalyzer evidence obtained after McPhail was arrested for driving while impaired by alcohol and over-80, and unnecessarily strip searched.  The explanation a police officer offered to the court for the strip search was that a cell phone was found in McPhail’s shoe and there might be something else secreted on him. Again, no records were kept of the search, and no approval to strip search McPhail was sought from a staff sergeant. Ultimately, Justice Maresca found that the police conduct “both in conducting the strip search and in attempting to hide it at trial” made the seriousness of the state conduct and impact on the accused’ Charter protected rights “especially egregious”. After the evidence was excluded, McPhail was acquitted. A spokesperson for the Peel Police Service stated that the force will “look into” the court’s findings of misconduct.

In spite of widespread calls for increased police training and reporting when it comes to conducting searches and the ensuing litigation that the taxpayer is left on the hook for ten years after guidelines were issued to the police and public, what should be done to streamline compliance and police accountability?

Posted by Jeremy Tatum (Windsor Law III)

Tuesday, March 15, 2011

Ottawa Police Officer charged with sexual assault of Stacy Bonds

Following a lengthy investigation, the SIU has decided to lay a charge of sexual assault against Sgt. Steve Desjourdy of the Ottawa Police Service for his conduct during a unconstitutional strip search of Stacy Bonds.

For a legal argument that the facts of the case meet the Supreme Court of Canada's legal test for the actus reus of sexual assault, see David M. Tanovich, "Bonds: Gendered and Racialized Violence, Strip Searches, Sexual Assault and Abuse of Prosecutorial Power" (2011), 79 Criminal Reports (6th) 132.

Monday, December 13, 2010

CBC's The Current examines strip searches

As noted on The Current's website:

PART TWO

Strip-Searches - Roberta Walker

It has been nine years since the Supreme Court of Canada prohibited strip-searches as a routine police practice. But just last month, the issue boiled over again, after a judge in Ottawa chastised local police for their un-provoked and violent strip-search of an innocent woman named Stacey Bonds. The Supreme Court handed down its ruling in December of 2001.

The case centered around Ian Golden, a black man who was strip-searched by Toronto police in a downtown restaurant. The Supreme Court ruled that strip-searches may only be done out of clear necessity with the permission of a supervisor and by members of the same sex.

But despite that ruling, strip-searches continue to be a common and controversial police practice. Freelance producer Roberta Walker has been looking into the issue. She was in Ottawa.

The Current interviewed Professor Tanovich who argued R. v. Golden in the Supreme Court of Canada.

Saturday, December 11, 2010

The Crown should align with justice, not the police

By David Tanovich, The Ottawa Citizen December 11, 2010

With heightened public concern over the recently revealed treatment of Stacy Bonds, Terry Delay, Adam Nobody (G-20) and other high-profile cases, people are likely wondering whether police violence is on the rise. The answer is probably no. But that answer is of little comfort. The critical question is why we have not seen a reduction in the unjustified use of violence given the number of positive developments in policing.

Over the last 20 years, there has been a greater move toward civilian oversight of policing including the creation of the Special Investigations Unit (SIU) in Ontario. The video camera is now a staple in police stations and so the police know they are being watched. We have seen a new breed of police chiefs who are reflective and thoughtful leaders. As well, police services have begun to focus on ensuring a diverse force, community outreach, sensitivity training and developing a culture of professionalism.

So why have these developments not had the desired effect? That is a complex question. One explanation is that there remains a police culture of impunity that has yet to be penetrated. It is a culture which leads otherwise good and well-meaning individuals to believe and act as if they are "the law" or "above the law." This is the power of culture over individual will. Until this culture is addressed, any accountability reforms will ultimately fail to have their desired effect.

What often gets overlooked in the discussion of this issue is the role that lawyers, criminal justice academics, judges and juries play in enabling a culture of police impunity.

I want to focus here on the role of one such actor - the Attorney General of Ontario.

The Attorney General has an ethical and constitutional obligation to ensure that his prosecutors remain independent and do not "align" themselves with the police. In some jurisdictions, this line has been crossed. This sends a powerful message to the police to carry on and not to worry because the Crown "has our back" to put it in the vernacular. Consider the following cases.

Last year, the Ontario Privacy Commissioner released her report which examined the practice of Crown jury vetting. Her review found that one-third of Crown offices had asked police to violate our privacy laws and to conduct computer checks of prospective jurors, beyond the required criminal record check. In Barrie, for example, the police were asked to provide any information to ensure that jurors "we" would not want could be removed. As the Ontario Court of Appeal observed two weeks ago, "[t]his use of police resources and attempt to align the Crown with the police is inconsistent with Crown counsel's obligation to ensure that the accused receives a fair trial."

In R. v. Tran, the Crown failed to distance itself from the police misconduct. In that case, the Crown invited an officer to sit with him during the trial and to assist with witness preparation. The officer had gratuitously assaulted the accused when he turned himself in and then destroyed evidence and committed perjury to hide the abuse. In June, the Ontario Court of Appeal stayed the accused's conviction for conspiracy to commit robbery. It issued a stern reprimand observing that the Crown's conduct reflected an "indifference to, if not approbation of, the police abuse and attempted coverup" and that the "Crown's conduct was evocative of an alignment with the police, notwithstanding the abuse."

And most recently in the Bonds case, we see perhaps one of the most egregious instances of "police alignment." As we now know, this was not a case of a young prosecutor making an error in judgment. We have been told that a case management team as well as senior Crowns in the Ottawa office approved her prosecution. So why, upon considered reflection, did they reach their decision when the shocking videotape evidence revealed that she was the victim, not the police? Why did they ignore the very real possibility that Bonds was sexually assaulted by the officers? And why did they ignore that there was, in fact, no offence committed since individuals are entitled to use reasonable force (such as kicking) to resist an unlawful arrest and assault by police? There is no reasonable explanation other than they stepped out of their shoes as ministers of justice to protect the officers.

Who knows how many other cases involving trumped up charges such as public intoxication, assault police or cause disturbance are out there where the Crown is acting out of a concern for the officers and not the public interest? For example, why is it only now that the Ottawa Crown's office has exposed the two most recent cases of videotaped police misconduct? Would it have done this without the chief's request or the public attention?

Ultimately, the conduct of prosecutors is the responsibility of the Attorney General of Ontario who has the power to discipline them and set policy on when a prosecution should be stopped. Where is he on this issue of the crossing of the line? Why hasn't he had the courage we have seen exhibited last week by Deputy Chief Gilles Larochelle to acknowledge that there is a "problem" with many of his prosecutors?

Why has the Attorney General not yet addressed whether or not he will discipline the prosecutors engaged in unlawful jury vetting? Why has he not publicly acknowledged the misconduct in Tran? Why has he taken the extraordinary step of defending the prosecutors in the Bonds case, suggesting that there was a reasonable prospect of conviction?

It would seem that in this province, at least, the Attorney General is the lawyer for the police, not the public interest. And until he fulfils his constitutional role, the culture of impunity will grow.

© Copyright (c) The Ottawa Citizen

Friday, November 19, 2010

What were the prosecutors thinking?

By David M. Tanovich, Ottawa Citizen Special November 19, 2010

By now most people are familiar with the horrific experience of Stacy Bonds, the young woman who was arrested for effectively asking why she had been stopped and questioned by the police and then assaulted, strip-searched and detained half-naked for over three hours in a police cell. Her charge of assaulting police was stayed by Justice Richard Lajoie who concluded that there was no lawful authority for any of the conduct of the police that night and that what had happened to Bonds was an "indignity towards a human being."

While the focus has quite properly been on the conduct of the police officers involved, less attention has been placed on the Attorney General, the Crown Attorney's Office and the prosecutor, all of whom it seems believed that prosecuting Bonds for a minor offence in these circumstances was in the public interest.

It bears repeating that the purpose of a prosecutor is not to secure a conviction but to serve as a minister of justice. To ensure that the administration of justice is not tainted by conduct that subverts the rule of law.

Well before the trial, the Crown had seen the videotape. What did it show him? In addition to having a hand shoved down Bonds' pants and twice violently kneed in the back, she was strip-searched in the presence, and with the assistance, of male officers, one of whom forcibly cut her shirt and bra off with a pair of scissors. She was then left half-naked in a cell for over three hours. When she was found, her pants were soiled.

In R.v. Golden, the leading constitutional case on strip-searches, the Supreme Court of Canada recognized that "[w]omen and minorities in particular may have a real fear of strip searches and may experience such a search as equivalent to a sexual assault." Indeed, as Bonds puts it, "I was mentally and verbally raped."

The trial judge concluded that the only reasonable explanation for the officers' conduct was "vengeance and malice." He didn't link it to any prior event but presumably it was for Bonds' questioning the authority of the police earlier on the street. As Bonds is a black woman, there is also the lurking question of whether race and/ or gender were a factor not only in their decision to stop her on the street, but also to subsequently humiliate her. Given what we know about racism in policing and given that one of the officers was earlier temporarily demoted for assaulting and repeatedly Tasering a young woman in a cell less than a week before this incident, this is a very real likelihood.

Any reasonable Crown viewing the videotape would have concluded that the only offence it revealed was the assault and sexual assault of Bonds by the officers. Any reasonable Crown would have realized that Golden prohibits strip-searches of women by male officers absent extraordinary circumstances, and that without lawful authority, the non-consensual touching of a female suspect that interferes with her sexual autonomy or dignity is a sexual assault. As the trial judge pointed out, there was no lawful authority for any of the officers' conduct in this case.

Had the Crown Attorney's office properly examined this case and identified it as a serious incident, the case would have come to the attention of the chief of police. It is hard to criticize Chief Vern White or his executive for inaction when not only was the matter not brought to their attention but an independent agency was prepared to prosecute and defend the officers' conduct. Even during the trial, the Crown prosecutor was given the opportunity to do the right thing and withdraw the charges but presumably after getting instructions from his superior, he persisted.

In staying the proceedings against Bonds, the trial judge held that to continue the prosecution would be a "travesty" and that "I certainly would not be a party to such an action." The question is why the prosecutor and his office permitted itself to be a party.

What remains to be seen is how our system responds. One officer has been banned from dealing with the public and an internal investigation has been launched. But will the province's Special Investigations Unit investigate the case as this conduct should be deemed to fall squarely within their mandate? Will these officers be charged with assault causing bodily harm and/or sexual assault? And finally, will the public find out why the Attorney General continued to prosecute Bonds in these circumstances and failed to denounce what happened to her?

David M. Tanovich is a professor of law at the University of Windsor and academic director of the Law Enforcement Accountability Project (LEAP).
© Copyright (c) The Ottawa Citizen

Sunday, August 1, 2010

Supreme Court of Canada upholds Charter damages for unconstitutional strip search of lawyer

In Vancouver (City) v. Ward, 2010 SCC 27, the Supreme Court of Canada addressed, for the first time, when damages are an appropriate section 24(1) remedy. Cameron Ward, a Vancouver lawyer, was mistakenly arrested following the police receipt of information that an individual intended to throw a pie at the Prime Minister. Following his arrest, Ward was strip searched. The Court, in affirming the decision of the lower courts, held that he was entitled to damages of $5,000 as the search violated section 8 of the Charter.

McLachlin C.J., writing for the Court, determined that the language of section 24(1) is broad enough to include constitutional damages for Charter breaches. The Supreme Court developed a four step test. First, the claimant must first demonstrate that a Charter right has been breached. The next step assesses whether damages will further an identified purpose including compensation, vindication of the right and deterrence. Compensation refers to the objective of restoring a claimant to the position he would have been in had the Charter breach not occurred. Vindication of a right is meant to underscore the severity of a constitutional breach, and the objective of deterrence is to prevent future breaches.

The third step gives the state an opportunity to rebut the award of damages by demonstrating that countervailing factors exist to defeat the functional objectives rendering damages “inappropriate or unjust”. One countervailing consideration is the availability of other remedies such as private law remedies and declarations. For instance, if a claimant received damages resulting from concurrent tort action, the state could argue that that remedy addressed the constitutional breach. Importantly, the Court held that a person seeking Charter damages need not have exhausted all other legal remedies available, as long as the claimant can demonstrate damages would satisfy one of the objectives mentioned. The last step is to determine the quantum of the damages. Damages must be fair to both the claimant, which takes into consideration a number of factors such as the seriousness of the Charter breach and the risk of diverting resources from public programs to settle private matters.

As for the application of the facts to the case, the Court determined that damages should be awarded. First, there was no issue that the applicant had his section 8 right to be free from unreasonable search violated by the strip search. Second, compensation was necessary because the applicant suffered a serious injury. The Court reiterated that strip searches are inherently humiliating and degrading. Moreover, Ward posed no threat to himself or others, and had the police been more sensitive to his Charter rights the search would have been deemed unnecessary. In addition, the serious violation warranted damages to further satisfy the objectives of vindication and prevent future abuses of these rights. With regards to the third step, the state did not provide countervailing factors to the awarding of damages.

Finally, in assessing the quantum of damages, the Chief Justice stated that the claimant, having been strip searched, suffered significant injury to his intangible interests. However, the search was brief and not “extremely” disrespectful since Mr. Ward was not forced to remove his underwear, he was not touched, and it did not appear as if he suffered any physical or psychological injury. With respect to vindication and deterrence, while the officers’ conduct was insensitive to Mr. Ward’s Charter rights, the strip search was neither malicious nor intentional and, therefore, substantial damages are not necessary. Therefore, damages in the amount of $5,000 was appropriate.

Do you think that the Court’s recognition of damages as a constitutional remedy will help deter and prevent abuse of Charter rights?

Posted by Kenny Leung (Windsor Law II)