Friday, June 19, 2009
Military police watchdog probes transfers to torture
However, the MPCC’s importance as a civilian oversight mechanism for the Canadian Forces’ roughly 1200 MPs has become apparent in the last year. First of all, its 2008 case load – with 92 new files opened - was the highest since its creation ten years ago. Second, its current probe into the activities of Canadian military police in Afghanistan promises real relevancy and, more importantly, the possibility of shining light on the treatment of detainees by Canadian troops. With a 2008 Federal Court ruling (confirmed by the Federal Court of Appeal with application for leave to the Supreme Court of Canada dismissed in May 2009) that the Charter does not apply to the actions of Canadian Forces personnel in their treatment of Afghan citizens in Afghanistan – even when detainees are under the Forces’ direct control – the judiciary appears to have foreclosed the possibility of judicial oversight of expeditionary military action. Furthermore, the military’s internal investigatory procedures – both the investigation ordered by the Provost Marshall and the Boards of Inquiry ordered by top brass – have found no wrongdoing. And yet there are many unanswered questions. Chief among them is this: why did the Canadian Forces - contrary to our obligations under International Humanitarian Law and the UN Torture Convention - transfer Afghan detainees to prospective torture at the hands of local authorities? And what omissions or commissions did MPs commit in the transfers to torture?
The MPCC’s decision to hold a Public Hearing into the Afghan detainees came in March 2008, roughly one year after its investigation was launched and after the failure of various government departments to fully provide the MPCC with documents necessary for its investigation. Hearings began at the end of May of this year and, after 5 days of establishing the wider context of the Canadian Forces engagement in Afghanistan, will reconvene in October.
It should be noted that the MPCC’s hearings are operating under a cloud. The federal government has brought an application for judicial review into the Commission’s decision to hold a public hearing, arguing that the inquiry does not involve members of the military police in the performance of any “policing duties or functions”. Fortunately, the government’s request for a stay of the hearings until the full judicial review application is heard was refused by the Federal Court in April 2009.
One of the complainants before the MPCC, Ottawa University’s Prof. Amir Attaran, has criticised commission counsel for taking a non-adversarial approach at the start of the May hearings. However, given the Commission’s determination to go ahead with the hearing despite vigorous government opposition, and its wide subpoena powers, the hearings this coming fall do offer the best prospect of accountability for the transfers to torture.
Posted by Professor Christopher Waters, University of Windsor, Faculty of Law
Wednesday, June 10, 2009
Jury vetting exposed in Windsor and Essex County
At the end of May, the practice of jury vetting was first reported by the National Post. The Post described how several police forces had been involved in providing information to Crown Attorneys involving whether potential jurors had been charged with a minor offence, had charges dropped or had been involved with the mental health system. The Juries Act does not permit such background checks. Indeed, “[t]here are instead strict rules that restrict the Crown and defence to knowing only the name, address and occupation of a potential juror from court records.” However, when the issue was raised by the defence at the trial of Zoldi and Huard, Justice Thomas found that a much more personal commentary of potential jurors had been provided to the Windsor Crowns. Police had made notations beside prospective jurors’ names after completing background checks. During the four-day hearing concerning whether illegal juror background checks had taken place, Windsor police Detective Mark Denonville admitted that he had “offered” to do background checks on prospective jurors, and that he and a colleague “made notes” on the information they discovered using the police database. The notations included criminal charges, regardless of whether there was a conviction, simple highway traffic offences and convictions from before the potential jurors were even legal adults. One officer wrote beside a prospective juror’s name: “Doesn’t like police.”
The practice raises a number of legal and ethical issues. Prosecutors are Ministers of Justice whose goal is to protect the public interest not to use any means necessary to secure a conviction. They also have a constitutional and ethical obligation to disclose any relevant information. Both of these duties appear to have been breached. There is a need for the Ministry and/or Law Society of Upper Canada to conduct an investigation into these cases.
There are also privacy issues and concerns about the impact this scandal will have on the administration of justice and the willingness of individuals to serve on juries. These concerns were aptly raised in an editorial in today's National Post entitled "Twelve Vetted Men".
On the issue of privacy, Ontario's Information and Privacy Commissioner today launched an investigation into whether the privacy rights of prospective jurors were breached by the background checks.
This issue also raises alarm bells over what kind of information is collected by the police and stored on their computers. What makes it particularly problematic is the inability of individuals to ever review the information and/or have it expunged.
Finally, there is the question of the impact of these revelations on ongoing trials and convictions obtained in these jurisdictions. There are potentially hundreds of cases in jeopardy and subject to some kind of review.
Posted by Professor David M. Tanovich
Tuesday, June 9, 2009
City of Montreal loses racial profiling appeal
Montreal, June 9, 2009 --- The Quebec Superior Court has thrown out a judicial review case brought by the City of Montreal against the Quebec human rights commission and CRARR.
In a decision dated June 2, 2009, Madam Justice Hélène Lebel rejected the City's argument that a person found guilty in municipal court over a city by-law cannot file a civil rights complaint against the police for having engaged in racial profiling leading to the issuance of a ticket. For the City, the filing of the discrimination complaint is tantamount to a disguised appeal.
The case involved a complaint filed by CRARR in September 2003 on behalf of a Black minor, F.F., in the East-end district of Saint-Michel, who was fined by the police for “incivilities” (i.e. using urban property for a purpose other than that for which it is designed - the youth was sitting on a small fence in front of his public housing project).
Of the many youths present, the police officers only singled out Black boys for citation; racially discirminatory comments were also directed towards these youths. In January 2004, the youth in question was found guilty by default, for failing to appear in court to contest his fine. In December 2007, the human rights commission ruled that the youth was the victim of racial profiling and recommended $10,000 in damages. Two other Black boys were also fined by the police (one of whom was under 14 and could not be fined under Quebec law); the human rights commission also recommended $10,000 for each of them.
Since the City refused to comply with the commission's decision, the case was brought before the Quebec Human Rights Tribunal, as with all cases of racial profiling. In August 2008, the Quebec Human Rights Tribunal dismissed the City's contention that it did not have the jurisdiction to hear it; the City filed for judicial review before the Quebec Superior Court, which now sends the case back to the Human Rights Tribunal for a hearing on the merit of the cases.
In recent months, the City has systematically challenged racial profiling cases on procedural grounds before the courts. To date, the City has lost despite its numerous actions to prevent the Human Rights Tribunal from proceeding.
The Montreal Police continues to apply its policy against incivilities, which has deemed in New York City and in many cities in France to be discriminatory towards youths of color and the poor. Under this policy, many young males of color, disadvantaged youths as well as the homeless have been fined for conduct deemed by the police to be “uncivil” (spitting, talking loud, jaywalking, etc.), resulting in penal (not criminal) records for many youths. Despite its application since 2001, the policy has never been the subject of public debate and evaluation at City Council.
Information : René Saint-Léger, Counsel
Fo Niemi, Executive Director
CRARR : 514-939-3342
Saturday, June 6, 2009
NDP introduce private member's bill to ban racial profiling in Canada
NDP Press Release
Thu 04 Jun 2009
OTTAWA - Bill Siksay (Burnaby-Douglas) has again tabled in the House of Commons a Private Member’s Bill that seeks to ban racial and religious profiling by federal law enforcement agencies and officials.
The bill is in response to concerns raised about the practice of racial and religious profiling, and stems from consultations held by the New Democrats during the 38th and 39th Parliaments. It requires federal law enforcement agencies to ban racial and religious profiling and report to Parliament on their actions, and requires agencies to do an analysis of how racism plays a role in the law enforcement context.
“Racial and religious profiling has been very serious and costly to those who have been its victims. Such actions by law enforcement officers and agencies are based solely on false stereotypes. It is bad public policy and bad law enforcement practice, plain and simple”, said Siksay. “This bill will ensure sound policy and procedure is developed and maintained by all federal law enforcement agencies.”
The bill was seconded by Libby Davies (Vancouver East) who tabled an earlier version of it in the 38th Parliament.
CSIS did not disclose informant failed polygraph
Friday, June 5, 2009
More complainants come forward in case against OPP officer charged with using false evidence to issue tickets
This morning, the Star reported that Farzooq Sayed was pulled over by Mahoney-Bruer last Halloween and was ticketed for driving 156 km/hr. Sayed agrees that he was speeding, but alleges that he was not going as fast as 156 km/hr. Sayed recalls: “[t]he police officer came up to my window and the first thing he asked me was, ‘[w]hose car is this?’” Sayed is a 23-year-old racialized man, a student at Centennial College, and drives a Porsche Carrera 4S.
Ismet Breznica, another alleged victim of Mahoney-Bruer’s alleged arbitrary ticketing, was informed earlier this week that the two charges laid against him have now been stayed. Breznica reports that when he inquired with Mahoney-Bruer as to why he was being pulled over, the officer responded by saying “[t]oday I’m only picking white cars.” Breznica was driving a white 2008 Mercedes-Benz. In the Star this morning, Breznica is quoted saying “[s]ometimes it makes me wonder if I want to live my whole life in this country. Don’t treat me like a criminal. I’m not a criminal…”
According to the Star, since Mahoney-Bruer’s charges were reported last week, as many as 250 provincial charges laid by him are now under review. One of the most integral questions to be asked will be why Mahoney-Bruer was doing this, if it is found that he was. Did the race of the drivers play a role? After Sayed’s report it is now clear that at least one complainant is racialized. Is this the case for all of the alleged false arrests? As more people come forward, this information may be unveiled. In the meantime, LEAP hopes that the OPP will consider the role that race may have played during their investigation.
Posted by Ashley Paterson (Law II) (LEAP Summer Intern)
Activist group files complaint about investigation of Villaneuva death
The two officers involved in the shooting were never charged. However, when the inquest into Villaneuva’s death began last week it was discovered that those two officers were never even questioned during the investigation, but instead asked to provide written statements to the investigators a week after Villaneuva’s death. This aspect of the investigation stands in stark contrast to the treatment of civilian witnesses, who were “separated and questioned the night of the shooting.”
The inquest has been put on hold due to the Villaneuva family’s refusal to participate. This refusal stems in large part because of their desire dor a more thorough investigation into the systemic issues surrounding the shooting, such as racial profiling.
Posted by Ashley Paterson (Law II) (LEAP Summer Intern)
CSIS hid evidence in Harkat case
Posted by Professor Jasminka Kalajdzic, University of Windsor, Faculty of Law
Wednesday, June 3, 2009
Older-model RCMP tasers fail test
Elliot confessed that it is the RCMP’s objective to test all of their weapons. He further stated that “I cannot tell you we have currently completed that testing.” To make matters worse, the RCMP’s testing of the Tasers did not reveal the same defects that were uncovered when the B.C. government tested them.
Before the order from the B.C. government, the RCMP were in the process of replacing the M-26 Taser models (the older models now being tested) with "'the more reliable' and smaller X-26 Taser,” the same model that four officers used to shock Robert Dziekanski, who died in 2007.
Elliot further stated that “[w]e want to make sure that the weapon…in the odd case that it is resorted to, that it does what our officers should expect it to do...”
Posted by Ashley Paterson (Law II) (LEAP Summer Intern)
Montreal taxi driver allegedly pulled over and fined on account of race
After David Bastien, a 25-year-old Haitian taxi driver in Montreal, was pulled over and allegedly “unfairly handcuffed” and fined by Constable Jean-Francois Croteau, concerns about why this happened and why it has happened more than once are surfacing.
On April 5, 2009, David Bastien reports that he was ordered by Croteau to pull over and provide his driver’s license. He further alleges that Croteau pulled him out of his car and handcuffed him. Croteau proceeded to issue four fines against Bastien, reports the Montreal Gazette. The fines included:
Since the incident, Bastien has gone to the Quebec Human Rights Commission and the Police Ethics Commission with his case against Croteau, but both Commissions are yet to hear it. According to the Gazette the complaints filed by Bastien state, among other things, that “most taxi drivers are afraid of reprisals by police and do not have confidence in the complaint procedure.” The precise evidence that Bastien has to substantiate this claim, if any, is unknown. However if proven to be true, it is a powerful proposition, especially considering that this is not the first time recently that a Montreal taxi driver has been detained and issued what seems to be an outrageous amount of tickets at once. In March and May, respectively, another officer, Constable Pierre Belanger, issued $600 in tickets to one cab driver and $2,310 in tickets to another. Both Croteau and Belanger work out of Station 21. When asked about these incidents, Commander Alain Simoneau replied that “[t]his is not a situation of racial profiling in any way,” but “application of the highway code, pure and simple.” Whether such a response will placate taxi-drivers in Montreal is yet to be seen. However, with the recent incident in Ottawa regarding an alleged police attack on a taxi-driver, drivers are being given more and more reasons to distrust the police. It seems too coincidental that all four taxi drivers in these two cases are racialized.
Posted by Ashley Paterson (Law II) (LEAP Summer Intern)Tuesday, June 2, 2009
Chair of the Commission for Public Complaints Against the RCMP reports on inadequate RCMP investigation
St. Arnaud was killed by Constable Ryan Sheremetta on December 19, 2004. St. Arnaud broke into a pharmacy that night, causing Sheremetta to respond to the call. Constable Colleen Erickson also responded to the call in a separate police car. Sheremetta saw St. Arnaud running from the mall where the pharmacy was located and pursued him in his police car. Ultimately, Sheremetta continued the pursuit on foot. Then, when Sheremetta was yelling for St. Arnaud to stop running, St Arnaud turned around and came back towards Sheremetta. Sheremetta says that he then fell on his back, from which position he shot St. Arnaud 3 times in the chest. Constable Erickson’s story is different, however. She says that she observed Sheremetta, while standing in a police shooting stance and not on his back as he reported, shoot twice at St. Arnaud from a distance of approximately ten feet. The autopsy showed that St. Arnaud was shot 3 times.
On March 15, 2006, the Chair of the Commission for Public Complaints against the RCMP, Paul Kennedy, initiated a complaint regarding the St. Arnaud case. The complaint addressed whether members of the RCMP improperly entered into a situation with St. Arnaud that resulted in his death and whether a member of the RCMP improperly discharged his firearm in the incident. The complaint was later amended to question whether members of the RCMP failed to conduct an adequate investigation into the death of St. Arnaud.
Eventually, the RCMP began an investigation as a result of the complaint. The results of the investigation were reported in the Commissioner’s Final Report dated June 26, 2008. This report stated that RCMP members properly responded to the break-in; that Constable Sheremetta’s actions were reasonable because he believed he would suffer grievous bodily harm or death, and that generally the RCMP conducted an adequate investigation into St. Arnaud’s death.
On October 29, 2008 the Commission concluded generally in its interim report that some elements of the RCMP investigation in St. Arnaud’s death were inadequate, some elements of the RCMP investigation into St. Arnaud’s death lacked impartiality, and that the investigative team failed to follow the Major Case Management Model.
The Commission’s findings and recommendations stated, among other things, that “it is imperative that the RCMP foster the confidence of the Canadian public by demonstrating that it embraces the best practices of a policing organization…it is not helpful for the RCMP to engage in rationalization and minimization…A frank acknowledgement of deficiencies or errors, where they exist, would serve not only to establish that the RCMP is accountable for its actions but that it is a principled organization worthy of the public trust.”
Posted by Ashley Paterson (Law II) (LEAP Summer Intern)
Monday, June 1, 2009
Demands that Villaneuva inquest consider racial profiling as factor in police shooting of unarmed Hispanic teenager in Montreal
Last August, Mr. Villaneuva died after being shot twice as police tried to arrest his brother, Dany. The police officer who shot Mr. Villaneuva, Constable Jean-Loup Lapointe, said he fired when the group tried to overpower him and his partner. Two other men with Mr. Villaneuva were shot during the altercation, but survived.
The Villaneuva family and the two other men that were shot had been designated as “interested parties” by the coroner, but while the province agreed to pay for legal representation for the Villaneuva family, it refused such compensation for the other two men. Both parties withdrew as a result. Most of the intervener groups, which previously included civil-rights defenders and race-relations activists, have also withdrawn. Only five interveners remain and all represent the police.
Last Tuesday, Public Security Minister Jaques Dupuis stated that he would provide for the legal costs of any interested parties that could assist with the inquiry. However, legal fees are not the only concern. The victims and the Villaneuva family believe the inquest to be too narrowly-focussed. They want the investigation to go beyond Mr. Villaneuva’s death and examine issues such as racial profiling by police, the disproportionate number of visible minorities among victims of police shootings and the socio-economic situation in Montreal North.
The Villaneuvas and the two other victims have chosen to stand up to a situation that they foresee creating an unfair result. They clearly have no interest in an investigation that will reveal what they likely don’t believe; that the fatal shooting was provoked. With an inquest that even the coroner believes to be skewed in favour of the police, their concern seems to be well-founded. More appropriately, they would like the investigation extended beyond Fredy’s death to the systemic issues taking place in Montreal North, often referred to as the city’s Bronx. Their boycott of the inquest has not, as of yet, produced any positive results. The situation has seemed to remain at a standstill since last week. However, if nothing else, their boycott on the inquiry has brought an awareness of issues of poverty and racial inequality into the public forum once again. Hopefully, the case will cause the public to increase the standard of accountability they require from officers in “the Bronx.”
Posted by Ashley Paterson (Law II) (LEAP Summer Intern)
Sunday, May 31, 2009
OPP officer charged after allegedly using false evidence to lay speeding charges
The alleged false charges have led the OPP to begin a review of traffic stops and some criminal cases. Prosecutors and the OPP will review Mahoney-Bruer’s past cases to see if there is any evidence of other suspicious activity, but the police have not determined nor disclosed how in depth or far-reaching this investigation will be. However, Mahoney-Bruer has worked for the OPP for 12 years.
Thus far the response of the OPP is positive, as it was quick to initiate the investigation. At this point no motive for the alleged false charges has been disclosed, but in order to restore public confidence in OPP officers involved in highway traffic enforcement, one may be required. OPP commissioner Julian Fantino wrote in a statement regarding the charges "I believe that the public trust is a fundamental cornerstone of the OPP and policing."
Posted by Ashley Paterson (Law II) (LEAP Summer Intern)
Thursday, May 28, 2009
Court of Appeal allows police disclosure of withdrawn charges pursuant to a consent for a Vulnerable Persons Search
The respondent, Tadros, had been charged with four counts of sexual assault and four counts of sexual exploitation against children who lived in his group home. Ultimately, the charges were withdrawn when Tadros entered into a peace bond. Subsequently, Tadros sought employment and consented to a Criminal Records Search and Vulnerable Persons Search by the Toronto Police Service. When he learned that the Peel Service had disclosed the charges to the Toronto Police Service, Tadros brought an application for an order requiring the Peel Police Service to expunge any reference to the withdrawn criminal charges from their records. He was successful in the lower courts.
The Court of Appeal allowed the appeal and set aside the injunction. The Court reasoned that because Tadros had already received the results of a Criminal Records Search and was then asked for further consent to disclose additional information for the Vulnerable Persons Search, he should have reasonably assumed that information about the eight charges may be disclosed. Second, even if by consenting, he was unaware that the withdrawn charges would be disclosed, he became aware when he received the reports and was turned down for the jobs he was applying for. The Court, therefore, concluded that Tadros had given his consent to the disclosure of the eight charges, and therefore set aside the injunction order made by the Superior Court.
Tadros also cross-appealed the lower court holding that the disclosure of information did not violate his rights under sections 7 and 8 of the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms. The cross-appeals were dismissed. With regards to s. 8, the Court held that the respondent’s privacy was not violated because the Peel Police Service had lawfully obtained and retained the information. With regards to s. 7, the Court held that disclosure by one police service to another did not infringe on the respondent’s liberty or security of the person. Tadros also failed to identify an operative principle of fundamental justice even assuming there was an infringement of his liberty or security of the person.
Posted by Ashley Paterson (Law II) (Summer LEAP Intern)
Wednesday, May 27, 2009
How far-reaching are police checks of the background of prospective jurors in Ontario?
Jurors were not told of the background checks and the information was not disclosed to defence lawyers, as is required under the legal and ethical obligations of the Crown. Although individuals convicted of an indictable offence cannot serve as jurors, the information obtained by the Crown through the police databases allegedly detailed whether a potential juror had been charged with a minor offence, had charges dropped or had been involved with the mental health system.
These alleged background checks raise issues of transparency with respect to police forces in Ontario, the Ontario Ministry of the Attorney-General and the Crown offices in Barrie and Simcoe County. If, in fact, this practice has been going on since 2004 there are likely countless cases that have been affected by it. Why did police comply with such requests from the Crown? The CPIC code of ethics does not allow for the police databases to be used for this purpose. Unquestionably, jurors that have served in Simcoe County since 2004 will be left wondering exactly what information was obtained about them by various police services and ultimately surrendered to the Crown. It is now necessary for Barrie Police Services to explain why they have participated in such background checks, in order to restore their transparency and accountability to the public. Only then can “…the people affected by it…make their own decision about a remedy,” said Frank Addario, president of the Ontario Criminal Lawyers’ Association.
This week, the Ontario Ministry of Attorney-General issued a directive ordering Crowns to cease background checks and permitting only checks to ensure that prospective jurors had not been convicted of an indictable offence.
Posted by Ashley Paterson (Law II) (Summer LEAP Intern)
Tuesday, May 26, 2009
RNC Police Chief apologizes for conduct of officers who mistook autism for intoxication
To make matters worse, the second officer on the scene defended his actions on the CBC website. Responding to negative comments, the officer wrote “I challenge all you arm chair quarterbacks to spend a week in my job. I have 15 years on patrol, and can spot a person who needs help…”
Why did this happen? Chief Browne explains that the first officer on the scene was fairly young, and followed standard procedure, yet he concedes that the case could have been handled differently from the start. Unquestionably, an excuse regarding the inexperience of the officer is not enough. Police should be trained to adequately differentiate autism and other inherent conditions from intoxication and if there is any question as to whether the person is intoxicated a breathalyser should be administered. The RNC has made arrangements to start offering autism awareness training to officers. In fact, the RNC had already been proceeding with training on how to recognize and work with people with autism. Comparatively, in Detroit, police receive special training on how they should deal with handicapped, mentally ill, and homeless citizens. This training was adopted in 2003 as part of a program to increase sensitivity and accountability. For further discussion of the Detroit intiative, see Police taught proper response to mentally ill suspects.
Diane Spurell has been supportive of the RNC’s response since the incident and has dropped a criminal complaint against the officers. Hopefully, the new RNC training procedures will prevent similar incidents in the future.
Posted by Ashley Paterson (Law II) (LEAP Summer Intern)
Monday, May 25, 2009
Ottawa taxi driver case raises issues of racism, police accountability and transparency
Although the incident happened two weeks ago, no charges have been laid. The Special Investigations Unit (SIU) is investigating the off-duty officer’s actions to determine if charges should be laid at all.
This incident raises serious issues of both overt and systemic racism within the Ottawa Police Service. A 2006 census of the Ottawa Police found racialized individuals under-represented among its members, sometimes by large margins. It is a frightening incident for the Ottawa community to have a member of their police service allegedly act so overtly racist, and apparently not afraid to connect that racism to his identity as a police officer.
A second issue raised by this incident is the accountability of officers in the Ottawa Police Service. The reported reaction of the police officers that came to the scene is an indication that officers involved in criminal activity are treated much differently than are civilians. One would presume that if the assailant was a civilian he would have been handcuffed, put in the back of a cruiser and taken to the police station. The way the assailant was actually treated in this case sent a strong message to those who witnessed it; and later to those who read about it. As one witness has said: “It was like, ‘He’s a police officer, we care about him. You’re just a taxi driver, we don’t care about you.’”Further, without having laid charges to date, we are forced to question if this officer will be held accountable at all. In a similar attack on a citizen by police officers in Vancouver in January, charges were laid in one week.
Lastly, this incident also raises issues of transparency. To date, the name of the police officer has not been disclosed by the Ottawa Police Service. Since the investigation of the officers that came to the scene has been postponed until the assailant’s investigation is completed, one would hope that the assailant’s investigation would be completed promptly. Yet the Ottawa Police Service has remained quiet about the incident since the Chief of Police met with Airport taxi drivers the day after the incident. While the response from taxi drivers after that meeting was positive, I’m sure that two weeks later they are getting curious as to what might come of the case.
Posted by Ashley Paterson (Law II) (LEAP Summer Intern)
Sunday, May 17, 2009
CRARR releases "Any Negro Will Do" report on misuse of race in suspect descriptions
Montreal, Canada, May 6, 2009 --- Authorities must enact measures to prevent the police from using vague, race-based, suspect descriptions to stop and arrest young Black and other racialized men even when they do not resemble the suspect or when the description is so general that every male of colour can be subject to police stops. This is the main recommendation of a report released by CRARR today to highlight a frequent situation encountered by many innocent young men of colour who end up arrested and being roughed up by police officers due to mistaken identity. Produced with private donations and technical support from the Pro-Bono programs of the faculties of law of McGill, UQAM, and Université de Montréal, the 80-page report, entitled Any Negro Will Do: Race and Suspect Description - the Slippery Slope towards Racial Profiling, provides a detailed review of the practice. It reviews case law in Quebec and other provinces, and submits 11 recommendations for actions to
prevent such a practice.
Named after a popular American expression, the practice involves the police broadcast and use of vague suspect descriptions based only on race and gender (usually, “a Black man”) that leads officers to stop, detain, arrest and point guns at individuals whose looks often bear little resemblance to the suspect other than the fact that they share the same race. The problem can be compounded by the fact that many police officers lack training and personal knowledge with racial diversity, which can lead to further complications in identifying race (for instance, mistaking a South Asian for an Arab).
This practice can be a result of individual or institutional conduct based on conscious or hidden bias, ignorance or negligence. Since it involves the description of a specific person, race-based suspect descriptions that contain little information on features other than race and gender, differ from criminal profiling, which involves the elaboration of a profile of a group or type of persons likely to commit a particular crime based on a hosts of factors; and racial profiling, which involves using race as a proxy to subject all persons associated with that race to heightened scrutiny and differential treatments, without any valid motives or any report on a specific suspect.
As a result, race-based suspect descriptions, no matter how vague, tend to be considered as legitimate and necessary to police work, although there have been little public policy debates on the issue.
Further, the courts have generally been upholding the practice and ruling in favour of the police. The report examines specific decisions by the Supreme Court (R. v. Mann, 2004), and by other courts or tribunals in Ontario (R. v. Smith, Superior Court, 2004), Quebec (Commissaire à la déontologie policière c. Chan et Pépin, Police Ethics Committee, 2006) and Alberta (Coward v. Alberta Human Rights and Citizenship Commission, Court of Queen's Bench, 2008) that rejected victims' challenges to what is seen as racially biased police conduct and that upheld the constitutionality of the police stops and arrests.
To illustrate the problem, CRARR presents the stories of Black men in Montreal who have been the target of this “Any Negro Will Do” practice, including:
❏ A 19 year-old McGill Black student who came out of a Wyclef Jean concert at the Metropolis club and was arrested at gunpoint by the police acting on a report of a “Black man wearing red pants and carrying a gun” near the St-Laurent metro station. One officer even asked him if he belonged to a gang;
❏ A 21-year-old college student who was stopped at gunpoint by two officers in Laval when he was walking home at night and handcuffed. The police was looking for a “Black man with a backpack” and found that he matched the suspect description;
❏ A 28 year-old biracial man who was going from his car on Guy Street, to his workplace downtown, when he was cut off by a police car, arrested at gunpoint and handcuffed by a policewoman who also told him that his name was fake since no Black man could carry a “Québécois” name;
Reviewing Canada's international obligations on preventing racism in policing as well as policy actions in Quebec and Ontario on racial profiling, the report outlines challenges facing authorities and racialized communities with regard to race-based suspect description and calls for measures to protect people of colour from such abusive and dangerous police actions. Some of the report's recommendations to the government, police departments and civil rights watchdog agencies include:
❏ Officially recognize that the practice of using vague, race-based suspect descriptions is discrimination as it exposes all members of a racial group to disproportionate scrutiny and harm;
❏ Require that police suspect descriptions be more specific in terms of physical description (skin colour, height, weight, age group, etc.) and that they mention time and geographic scope to narrow the search and avoid casting the wide net of discrimination on all members of a racial group in the area;
❏ Avoid lengthy legal procedural challenges to claims by victims of the “Any Negro Will Do” practice and settle early, especially in cases of obvious mistaken identity and immediate admission of such an error by the police officers involved;
❏ Adopt policies enabling the Quebec human rights commission and the Quebec Police Ethics Commissioner to better handle complaints of the “Any Negro Will Do” practice. Pending such adoption, these agencies should suspend all decisions on these complaints to avoid inadequate investigation and incorrect analyses;
❏ Train future and current police officers, judges, and members of administrative tribunals on issues of race, racial profiling and race-based suspect description.
Source: Fo Niemi, Executive Director
Gabrielle Michaud Sauvageau, Communication and Research Officer
CRARR: (514) 939-3342
Friday, May 15, 2009
Refuse Profiling? The Supreme Court of Canada decision in R. v. Patrick
The trial judge held that Patrick did not have a reasonable expectation of privacy in the items seized from his garbage. The validity of the ensuing warrant was therefore upheld. This judgment was affirmed by the Alberta Court of Appeal which agreed that Patrick abandoned any privacy interest he had in the items by leaving them out for collection; and any trespass on his property was of a de minimis nature and did not violate his right to be free from unreasonable search and seizure under s.8 of the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms.
In R. v. Patrick, the Supreme Court of Canada upheld his conviction and dismissed the appeal. Justice Binnie, with concurring reasons from Justice Abella, held that Patrick had no expectation of privacy in the garbage, having abandoned it.
The court asked whether the actions of the accused, objectively viewed, would lead to a conclusion that Patrick continued his privacy interest(s) in the garbage. To answer this, the court adopted ‘The Totality of Circumstances Test’, which asks two primary questions:
(1) was there a subjective expectation of privacy; and
(2) was this expectation objectively reasonable.
Even though Patrick may have had a subjective expectation of privacy, the court relied on the issue of abandonment to answer the second question in the negative, finding no objective expectation of privacy in the garbage. Abandonment had occurred when Patrick placed the garbage out for collection in an unlocked receptacle on the boundary line of his property. As such, the court found that no violation of section 8 had occurred.
Justice Abella, in a concurring opinion (which does appear to dissent in part at times), did take issue with the State’s intrusion into one’s garbage issue. She indicates that:
“Individuals who put out their household waste as “garbage” expect that it will reach the waste disposal system: nothing more, nothing less. No one would reasonably expect the personal information contained in their household waste to be publicly available for random scrutiny by anyone, let alone the state, before it reaches its intended destination.”
She noted that there must be a “reasonable suspicion that a crime has been or is likely to be committed” before police should be allowed to search through ones garbage. Finding that such a suspicion existed in the present case, Justice Abella also found no violation of section 8.
The implications of this decision are particularly disturbing. It permits the authorities to profile problem neighbourhoods or problem buildings. In fact, Justice Binnie expressly noted that:
“Given the “totality of the circumstances” test, little would be gained by an essay on different variations of garbage disposal. To take a few common examples, however, the rural people who take their garbage to a dump and abandon it to the pickers and the seagulls, the apartment dweller who unloads garbage down a chute to the potential scrutiny of a curious building superintendent, and the householder who takes surreptitious advantage of a conveniently located dumpster to rid himself or herself of the “bag of information” are all acting in a manner inconsistent with the reasonable assertion of a continuing privacy interest, in my view.” (emphasis added)
There are many “problem” buildings in large urban cities like Toronto, Calgary and Vancouver. The decision in R. v. Patrick expressly permits the targeting and profiling of low income apartment buildings. “Reasonable suspicion” is an amorphous term that grants considerable power and discretion to the authorities. The decision effectively ignores the reality of how most Canadians dispose of their garbage. It implicitly privileges the living conditions of the middle class and upper class who enjoy a higher threshold of “reasonable suspicion” for criminal activity. The poor, marginalized and economically disadvantaged have always ‘enjoyed’ a lower threshold of “reasonable suspicion” for criminal activity.
Patrick may have been a producer of ecstasy, but the decision is far from bliss.
Professor Emir Aly Crowne Mohammed, and
Michael Barbero (Law II) University of Windsor, Faculty of Law