Wednesday, November 4, 2009

UN report critical of Canada's lack of attention to discrimination including racial profiling

A preliminary report compiled by Gay McDougall, the United Nation’s independent expert on minority issues, reveals that religious and ethnic minorities in Canada continue to experience discrimination in a number of key areas, including access to housing, employment, education, policing, justice and political participation.

McDougall spent 10 days touring Canada, meeting and speaking with minority groups about the obstacles they face in their everyday lives. McDougall concluded that although the federal and provincial governments have instituted “well-intentioned” policies, enforcement and implementation remain serious barriers to true inclusivity.

Key issues addressed in McDougall’s report include the failure of the federal, provincial and territorial governments to provide minority communities with equal access to housing, education, justice and political participation. McDougall also highlights the frustration that new immigrants feel when they are unable to use their foreign education credentials to obtain employment in their fields of expertise. Immigrant parents also reported concerns that school curricula do not accommodate different cultural backgrounds.

McDougall’s report also focused on alleged incidents of racial profiling and police brutality in a number of communities, including Vancouver’s Downtown Eastside and Montreal North. Minorities in these neighbourhoods reported feelings of distrust towards the police and a general lack of faith in the justice system.

McDougall’s report, which will be presented to the United Nations Human Rights Council, recommends that Canada refrain from using labels like “visible minorities” and instead seek to adopt terminology that will help reflect the vast diversity among minority groups and combat governmental discrimination.

While Canada portrays itself as one of the most multicultural nations in the world, it is evident from McDougall’s findings that it is time for Canadians to cast their glance inwards and consider what we can do to truly live up to our reputation as culturally conscious global citizens.

Posted by Claire Doughty (Law II)

Tuesday, October 20, 2009

Office of the Independent Police Review Director (Ontario) open for receiving police complaints

OIPRD Press Release

New Public Oversight Body Opens
First public complaint about the police can be filed October 19, 2009

NEWS
October 19, 2009
The Office of the Independent Police Review Director (OIPRD) officially opened its doors to the public today, bringing in new, stronger civilian oversight in Ontario.

The OIPRD was created in response to a report by the Honourable Patrick LeSage, recommending a new independent body to administer public complaints about the police in Ontario.

The OIPRD is an independent agency of the Ministry of the Attorney General responsible for receiving and dealing with all public complaints about the police in Ontario. The OIPRD’s goal is to provide independent, accessible and effective oversight of complaints that will build confidence and trust in the public complaints process.

QUOTES
“My team and I have worked hard over the past year to reach this point. In cooperation with the community and the police, we’ve developed the framework for a transparent and accountable system that will help enhance the positive relationship between the police and the community.”
—Gerry McNeilly, Independent Police Review Director

“I’m pleased that Ontario now has a complaints system that has the confidence and respect of both the public and the police. Civilian oversight contributes to public safety and is consistent with our government’s commitment to stronger, safer and more prosperous communities.”
—Chris Bentley, Attorney General

QUICK FACTS

The OIPRD can accept a complaint about any incident that occurred on October 19, 2009 or after.

Public complaints can be about any provincial, regional or municipal police officer in Ontario.

A complaint may be about the policies or services of a police department, or about the conduct of a specific officer.

LEARN MORE
Visit the OIPRD website to learn more about the public complaints system.
Read the Independent Police Review Act.
Allison Hawkins, Communications Branch 416-314-4517
www.oiprd.on.ca

Thursday, October 15, 2009

Was excessive force used in arrest of University of Western Ontario student?

The following video posted on YouTube shows a 22-year-old fourth year University of Western Ontario being arrested yesterday in the late afternoon for mischief, resist arrest, assault and escape police custody. Click here to watch the video.

According to the London Free Press article posted above:

"The video, shot by an unknown student, shows the suspect being kneed at least five times, struck with a telescopic baton at least six times and punched by one officer at least 27 times. The one minute, 32-second video shows four officers trying to subdue the suspect, who appears to be resisting and not complying with an officer’s demand to “stop resisting . . . give us your arms . . . stop resisting.” Thirty seconds into the video, two other officers arrive and join the others in trying to put the suspect in handcuffs. The suspect does appear to be resisting at times and police keep asking him to give them his arms."

The University issued a statement explaining the circumstances surrounding the student's arrest. Click here to read statement. According to the statement:

"The incident began shortly after 5 p.m., Wednesday, Oct. 14 when campus police were contacted by a student in the Social Sciences building who reported being followed by another student acting in a strange manner. A short time later, campus police received calls regarding a disoriented and threatening individual who had appeared on two different floors attempting to enter offices.

On the 8th floor, the suspect entered an office and attempted to force the occupant to leave. Being unsuccessful, the suspect left and subsequently barricaded himself in a 7th floor office. London Police were called. Two campus officers arrived on the scene and the suspect came out of the barricaded office and charged the officers in a violent manner. Other persons on the floor fled for their own safety and some locked themselves in their own offices. A third officer arrived and the three officers attempted to subdue the suspect, but he was able to break away from officers and fled.

On the main floor the suspect was stopped by a campus police officer and a confrontation took place as the suspect attempted to flee. London Police officers arrived on the scene to assist campus police and tried to subdue the suspect, who continued to fight violently and would not allow himself to be handcuffed. After numerous loud requests to the suspect to stop resisting, officers used punches and strikes to the suspect’s arms to apply handcuffs.

The suspect was eventually subdued and as he was being led outside, he began to fight once again. He was further restrained by officers. An ambulance arrived at this time. Paramedics had been called because officers felt the behaviour exhibited by the individual indicated he should be assessed at hospital. The resistance continued after the individual was transported to hospital. He was released into police custody at 3 a.m., Oct. 15. Police charged a 22-year-old fourth-year Social Sciences student with mischief, resisting arrest, assault, and escaping custody. He was described as 6 feet, 230 pounds. No weapon was believed involved."

Do you think that the force was excessive? Given that he was unarmed and not able to get off the ground, is it relevant what happened before he was taken to the ground in assessing the reasonableness of the force used? Is an individual truly resisting when they try to protect themselves from repeated blows from a baton, fist, knee?

Monday, October 12, 2009

Implicit racial attitudes and law enforcement shooting decisions

This article outlines a study which explores both the implicit and explicit racial attitudes that are linked with racial profiling and police shooting decisions within law enforcement. The author, Professor Katherine Tuttle summarizes a wide range of cognitive and psychological studies which all demonstrate that both White and Black individuals often associate black with negative stereotypes and white with positive stereotypes. Tuttle contests that because enforcement officers actually make shooting decisions, and undergo rigorous training on how to handle dangerous situations, it is important to study the police population separately in order to draw conclusions about variables influencing their behavior – an approach which has not been previously utilized. Therefore, Tuttle’s study compared the attitudes of college students to that of a group of police cadets who were all within 12 months of being hired (therefore, their racial attitudes couldn’t be attributed to the experiences they had working). The two groups were tested on a number of different racial dimensions and it was concluded that the police cadets not only presented much stronger negative racial biases towards Blacks than the students did, but were also more biased than a large, representative population. Tuttle concluded that while studying implicit attitudes that effect police behaviour present an exciting avenue to pursue, her research demonstrates that explicit attitudes are still very significant factors in the prediction of decisions making and should be continually examined.


Posted by Claire Doughty (Law II)

A loophole for the loot: CICB says officers welcome

A recent Toronto Star investigation into the Criminal Injuries Compensation Board (CICB) has revealed that since 2005, the Board has paid out an estimated $1.5 million in compensation to Ontario police officers who were injured while on duty.

Many families of victims are shocked at this finding, including Joe Wamback, whose son was brutally beaten by a gang of teens when he was 15. As a result of the beating, his son was on life support for two weeks and spent 7 months in the hospital. The Wambacks faced numerous delays in getting funds from the CICB for wheelchair and ambulance costs.

Professionals in the community are also appalled that police officers are able to claim compensation under the CICB. Dr. Leslie Balmer, a Peel Region psychologist who counsels families of murder victims, says that she thought the fund was “for victims of crime, not police officers ... doing their job." Similar sentiment is expressed by Osgoode Hall law professor, Alan Young, who told the Star that he is "somewhat shocked by the audacity that police forces feel they can tap into money that (is not) intended to assist them. It seems like this is double-dipping going on." Young further stated that, "you're actually making the pie smaller for deserving victims who have been complaining for a decade that the board is not responsive to their needs."

The Board was created under the Compensation for Victims Crime Act (R.S.O. 1990, CHAPTER C.24.)

The Act defines “victim” as, “a person injured or killed in the circumstances set out in section 5.” Section 5 reads:

Injuries compensable
5. Where any person is injured or killed by any act or omission in Ontario of any other person occurring in or resulting from,
(a) the commission of a crime of violence constituting an offence against the Criminal Code (Canada), including poisoning, arson, criminal negligence and an offence under section 86 of that Act but not including an offence involving the use or operation of a motor vehicle other than assault by means of a motor vehicle;
(b) lawfully arresting or attempting to arrest an offender or suspected offender for an offence against a person other than the applicant or his or her dependant or against such person’s property, or assisting a peace officer in executing his or her law enforcement duties; or
(c) preventing or attempting to prevent the commission of an offence or suspected offence against a person other than the applicant or his or her dependant or against such person’s property, the Board, on application therefor, may make an order that it, in its discretion exercised in accordance with this Act, considers proper for the payment of compensation to,
(d) the victim;
(e) a person who is responsible for the support of the victim;
(f) where the death of the victim has resulted, the victim’s dependants or any of them or the person who was responsible for the support of the victim immediately before his or her death or who has, on behalf of the victim or his or her estate and not being required by law to do so, incurred an expense referred to in clause 7(1)(a) or (e) arising from the act or omission. R.S.O. 1990, c. C.24, s. 5.

Given the language of Section 5(c), it does not preclude police officers from filing claims with the CICB. But what does the rest of the public think about that? Should police officers and prison guards who already have strong benefits as unionized employees be allowed to claim compensation from the Criminal Injuries Compensation Board? If the answer is no, then we must ask why this is happening. Have law enforcement agencies and departments been mismanaging their own funds meant for compensating police officers who are injured on duty? If the answer is yes, how can the Board ensure and show to the public that police applicants will not receive special or priority treatment over non-police applicants?

The Board’s website states that, “The role of the Board is to award financial compensation to victims of violent crimes committed in the Province of Ontario.” Injured police officers do need to go back to work and protect the public in a timely fashion, but are they really “victims”?
If reforms are not made to the current law and law enforcement officials continue to make successful claims with the Board, it is likely that the Board and police would both face serious harm to their reputation. As well, the public’s confidence in their elected members of government may further wane.

Posted by Agnes Tong (Law II)

Monday, October 5, 2009

Ontario's privacy commissioner finds systemic evidence of excessive background checks on jurors by Crowns and police and issues order to stop

News Release October 5, 2009

Commissioner Cavoukian Orders Crown attorneys to stop collecting personal information on prospective jurors – Recommends single screening process, in light of widespread background checks Investigation finds one-third of Crown attorney offices engaged in excessive background checks, in a practice that “should have been put to a stop 16 years ago.”

TORONTO – Ontario Information and Privacy Commissioner, Dr. Ann Cavoukian, today ordered Crown attorneys to cease collecting any personal information of potential jurors, beyond that which is necessary under the Juries Act and Criminal Code. Proposing a fundamental shift in the way that prospective jurors are screened, the Commissioner also called on the Ministry of the Attorney General (MAG) to implement a single, centralized juror screening process through the existing Provincial Jury Centre, minimizing the need for numerous background checks to be conducted across multiple offices. The new process addresses the lack of consistency in the “patchwork of practices” presently employed by Crown attorney offices and the police.
The Commissioner’s office (IPC) conducted a major investigation into whether the privacy rights of prospective jurors were breached when the police, on behalf of Crown attorneys, conducted background checks through a variety of means, ranging from accessing confidential databases, to informally gathering anecdotal information.

Key findings include:
•One third, or 18 of the 55 Crown attorney offices in Ontario had received background information about prospective jurors since March 31, 2006 – this practice extended well beyond the four locales previously identified in the media;

• All 18 Crown attorney offices had gathered personal information that exceeded the criminal conviction eligibility criteria set out in the Juries Act and Criminal Code – in doing so, they had also failed to comply with applicable privacy legislation; and

• There were varying practices regarding the disclosure of this information by Crown attorney offices to defence counsel.

“I want to be clear that we are not talking about a sweeping epidemic – in a relatively small number of cases, the violation of jurors’ privacy was a routine practice,” said Commissioner Cavoukian. “However, while these practices varied in terms of their invasiveness, the fact remains that 18 Crown attorney offices across the province gathered personal information that exceeded the criminal conviction eligibility criteria set out in the Juries Act and Criminal Code. What I find regrettable is that this invasive practice should have been put to a stop 16 years ago.”

Under the Juries Act and Criminal Code, an individual is ineligible to serve as a juror if they have been convicted of an indictable offence for which they have not received a pardon. The Criminal Code also allows a juror to be successfully challenged for cause by the Crown and defence counsel if they have been convicted of an offence for which a term of imprisonment exceeding 12 months has been given. The investigation found that practices had developed across Ontario that, in some cases, went far beyond these limits.

This issue of jury vetting was formally flagged by MAG in 1993, after Ontario Superior Court Justice Humphrey questioned the appropriateness of jury background checks. Within weeks, a memorandum on the issue had been written by a senior Crown attorney, culminating in a recommendation that the practice should stop. But it did not stop, and no further action was taken, at that time. Since then, a series of opportunities to provide clear guidance to Crown attorneys were missed, despite this issue surfacing again and again over the years. It was not until March 31, 2006 that a formal instruction to Crown attorneys came into effect, in the form of a MAG ‘Practice Memorandum.’

“Unfortunately, the 2006 Practice Memorandum was not sufficiently clear as to what practices were acceptable,” added the Commissioner. “We found that a patchwork of practices developed across the province, with a wide variety of opinions across Crown attorney offices as to what background checks were appropriate. My Order will hopefully provide clear direction as to what personal information may or may not be collected in the jury selection process.”

The Investigation
On May 25, 2009, media reports emerged that, in Barrie, Ontario, police services had been conducting background checks of prospective jurors, at the request of Crown attorneys. Upon learning that the practice extended beyond Barrie to include other Ontario locations, Commissioner Cavoukian launched an investigation under the Freedom of Information and Protection of Privacy Act and the Municipal Freedom of Information and Protection of Privacy Act into the practices of conducting background checks of prospective jurors, and whether these practices violated the privacy provisions of the legislation.

The Commissioner’s investigation received the full support of the Ontario Government. The Premier, the Honourable Dalton McGuinty, expressed the following view as part of a news conference: “The Attorney General has made it perfectly clear this is unacceptable, it’s not in keeping with practice and in fact, it’s against the law …. We will offer whatever cooperation is required in order to ensure that [Commissioner Cavoukian] can conduct whatever full review that she might and we look forward to receiving any recommendations.”

To ensure a comprehensive investigation, the Commissioner’s office pursued multiple channels of inquiry, including:

1. Conducting in-person interviews at four different Ontario locations with various parties: Crown attorneys, court staff, police officials and defence counsel;

2.Undertaking an intensive province-wide empirical survey of all 55 Crown attorney offices;

3.Receiving sworn affidavits from senior Crown attorneys;

4.Retaining the services of the Auditor General’s staff to review the document capture process involving jury lists; and

5.Receiving legal submissions from the Ministry of the Attorney General, the Ministry of Community Safety and Correctional Services, the Criminal Lawyers’ Association, the University of Toronto’s David Asper Centre for Constitutional Rights, and the Canadian Civil Liberties Association.

“We have made every effort to deliver a full review of the issues associated with background checks, and to provide workable solutions, to bring to an end any unacceptable practices,” said Commissioner Cavoukian.

The Order and Recommendations
Based on the findings of the investigation, the Commissioner is ordering Crown attorneys to cease collecting any personal information of potential jurors beyond that which is permitted under the Juries Act and the Criminal Code, relevant to criminal conviction eligibility.

Further, the Commissioner is recommending a fundamental shift in the way that prospective jurors are screened in Ontario. Proposing a complete overhaul of the existing system, the Commissioner has recommended that MAG, through its Provincial Jury Centre (PJC), be the only central body to screen jurors who are ineligible for jury duty, based on criminal conviction. As the single entity already in receipt of the names and personal information of all prospective jurors, the PJC is the obvious candidate to perform this role. Operating from a single location in London, Ontario, the PJC is also in an ideal position to implement strict privacy and security measures that can be strongly enforced, thereby providing a consistently high degree of protection for personal information.

In total, the Commissioner made 22 recommendations directed primarily at Ministry of the Attorney General (MAG), including:

•The Provincial Jury Centre of MAG should be the only central body to screen out jurors who are ineligible for jury duty, based on criminal conviction;
•Crown attorneys should cease the practice of requesting the police to provide criminal conviction information relating to potential jurors, barring exceptional and compelling circumstances;
•Where Crown attorneys do obtain criminal conviction information relating to prospective jurors, they should share this information with defence counsel, in accordance with MAG policy;
•MAG should re-write and re-design the jury service qualification questionnaire in order to make it more clear, transparent and user-friendly for all prospective jurors;
•MAG should develop and implement a policy for Crown attorneys on the appropriate retention and disposal of jury panel lists.

“Any practice that taints, or is perceived to taint, the jury process strikes at the heart of the values we share as citizens of a free and democratic society,” said Commissioner Cavoukian. “My Order and Recommendations should ensure that a number of important goals are met. Juror privacy will be enhanced, all parties to a criminal proceeding will have equal access to relevant information on prospective jurors, and we will have increased accountability surrounding the entire jury selection process.”
For a complete copy of the Order, visit www.ipc.on.ca

The Information and Privacy Commissioner is appointed by and reports to the Ontario Legislative Assembly, and is independent of the government of the day. The Commissioner's mandate includes overseeing the access and privacy provisions of the Freedom of Information and Protection of Privacy Act and the Municipal Freedom of Information and Protection of Privacy Act, as well as the Personal Health Information Protection Act, which applies to both public and private sector health information custodians, in addition to educating the public about access and privacy issues.

Media Contact:
Bob Spence
Communications Co-ordinator
Direct line: 416-326-3939
Cell phone: 416-873-9746
Toll free: 1-800-387-0073
bob.spence@ipc.on.ca

Thursday, October 1, 2009

Toronto Police Deputy Chief speaks publicly about racial profiling

This week, Deputy Chief Keith Forde, who is African Canadian, spoke publicly about racial profiling. In an address to a daylong conference hosted by the Toronto Police Service entitled Racially Biased Policing: Trends & Progressive Solutions, Deputy Chief Forde had this to say about racial profiling:

"This subject matter is extremely controversial and evokes different emotions. Often, people who have made the conscious decision not to police based on stereotypes and misgivings, but on evidence and facts are lumped in with those who do. Many times discussions break down when officers feel that they have been unfairly labelled as racially profiling, when they are not.

Officers don't feel like they have the ability to have an honest dialogue about the topic of racial profiling. They will either be labelled as traitors to their peers for pointing out behaviours that would constitute profiling, or they would be seen as racists for condoning behaviour that could be interpreted as profiling.

They often wonder "how do we know racial profiling even exists?"

Well, we know because it is a lived experience that has been shared among thousands. We know because our kids, our families and our friends tell us that it exists. We know because many of us have felt the sting of racial profiling at some point in our lives and it has rocked us to the core. We know because the community – through meetings, discussions and partnerships – has vocalized its opinions on what needs to happen at the Toronto Police Service. I don't say it with pride, but with purpose that I am intimately familiar with the topic of racial profiling – as an officer, a deputy chief and a black man...

Of everything I've learned and been told over the years, I can say with confidence that the following 10 statements accurately reflect what the community wants the police to know:

The police service must stop denying that racial profiling is a reality. It is problematic and no longer acceptable in a multiracial society as it feeds into negative stereotypes about certain groups, particularly, racialized groups such as African Canadians.

Communities are not fabricating racial profiling; it is an everyday lived reality.

Police services need to be cognizant and aware of the impact of racial profiling. Over-policing of certain communities, reinforcing negative stereotypes, lack of confidence in police, and combative relationships between the police and certain communities serve to erode the public's trust.

Racial profiling is a subconscious decision. Therefore, the police need to unpack their own stereotypical thinking. They need to become more conscious of their own biases and acknowledge that we all hold biases...

It is critical for those in senior management and the leaders of the police union to stop being so defensive and in such denial about racial profiling. It is time for them to support constructive and meaningful policies and procedures to address racial profiling.

Police officers always need to check their biases and stereotypes to ensure they are policing us all fairly and equally.

Racial profiling can serve to undermine an officer's ability to properly and effectively police and protect particular communities. The communities they protect include African Canadians who are also victims. If certain communities are perceived solely as perpetrators or criminals, then the services they receive or fail to receive will also be biased.

Racial profiling undercuts trust and works against crime prevention. If communities that are profiled don't trust the police, they will fail to report crime, cooperate with the police and seek the assistance and support of police in situations such as domestic violence.

This lack of trust can have serious consequences and backlash and serves to erode the safety and well-being of certain neighbourhoods and society as a whole.

The experience of racial profiling over a prolonged period of time has eroded the trust in certain communities within the police. The responsibility and duty to rebuild this trust lies primarily with the police.

You see, this is what the community is feeling. We cannot afford to ignore their profound experiences. We also must deal with how these same experiences are having an impact on our officers... Although we uphold and maintain the law, police aren't perfect. We are bound to make mistakes and that is okay. It's part of the human experience... The important part is that we as a service learn from the mistakes that are made and address them head-on with sound policies, training, improved supervision, community involvement and accountability...

When Bill Blair was appointed chief in 2005, one of the first things he did was to bravely admit that racial profiling did exist. He also vowed to work hard to change the systems that were complicit in upholding inequalities. At the Toronto Police Service, we have developed many ways to address the issue of racially biased policing and the overarching factors of prejudice and discrimination... Now we have a better and more positive relationship and understanding with Toronto's diverse communities, which helps us to better relate and work together."

This excerpt of his address was published as an opinion piece in the Toronto Star entitled "Feeling the Sting of Racial Profiling."

Toronto police service continues the fight against racial profiling

The Toronto Police Service has come a long way since former Chief, Julian Fantino, fervently denied a 2002 Toronto Star report alleging that racial profiling had infiltrated the ranks of Toronto’s police force. They have now publicly acknowledged that racial profiling is a very serious issue that needs to be exposed and dealt with appropriately. However, it is clear that there still remains plenty of room for further reform.

Current Chief Bill Blair has been heralded as the driving force behind the Police’s recognition that racial profiling is a problem that needs to stop being swept under the rug and instead has to be addressed head-on.

When the Police Board began its search for a new Chief in 2005, it had made a commitment to hire someone with a commitment to diversity issues. It was decided that Chief Bill Blair was the man for the job.

"Racism is a human failing. Racial profiling can occur. We've acknowledged that right upfront and that has really enabled us to work with our community partners to do something about it," said Blair. This attitude has lead to a renaissance in their diversity department.

This war against racial profiling has been waged on two fronts.

On the one hand, the Toronto Police have overhauled their recruitment policies and have installed efforts to go door-to-door in ethnic enclaves in search of recruits that better reflect the ethnic composition of the communities in Toronto. These efforts have led to tangible results in terms of a greater visible diversity present in the force.

On the other hand, the police have tried to address some of the ‘big picture’ systemic problems by inviting the Ontario Human Rights Commission to review all the organization’s policies and procedures. This process is still ongoing.

They have also begun to embrace a community-based policing model which puts front-line officers into a prevention role rather than focusing solely on enforcement. They hope that this approach will in turn begin to chip away at the distrust that has formed within these communities when dealing with police.

While there have been great strides made by the Toronto Police in the past five years, in terms of addressing racial profiling, everyone involved admits that there is no quick-fix solution to such a wide-spread problem and the fight will be ongoing.


Posted by Martin Mendelzon (Law II)

Friday, September 25, 2009

UofT Centre for Constitutional Rights concludes that jury vetting violates privacy of jurors

In June, the well-publicized scandal of jury vetting in several jurisdictions across Ontario was exposed. In short, several police forces had been providing information to Crown Attorneys about potential jurors, and the Crowns had not been in turn disclosing that information to defence counsel. The background checks being conducted on the jurors stepped over significant legal and ethical boundaries, investigating areas such as involvement with the mental health system and minor charges against jurors that had, often long before jury selection, been dropped.

After the exposure of the practice, Ontario’s Information and Privacy Commissioner launched an investigation, the results of which are yet to be seen.

However, the David Asper Centre for Constitutional Rights at the University of Toronto has since been asked to provide an opinion on the legality of the alleged background checks. As a result, the Centre has provided submissions regarding how the background checks impact the Charter rights of jurors and the accused, as well as submissions regarding the potential systemic significance of checks.

With respect to Charter rights, the Centre says that “the state conduct in these cases constituted an unreasonable search and therefore violated the s. 8 rights of potential jurors.” Further, the Centre reminds us that it is established law that any information obtained by the Crown regarding prospective jurors must always be disclosed to the defence. In terms of the systemic implications, the Centre points out the access to justice implications that arise from the checks. Specifically, potential jurors may not even know that their Charter rights have been breached. Without knowing, they cannot seek redress. Perhaps even more significant is that even if they did know, they would have no standing, and therefore no access to Charter breach remedies. A further systemic problem noted by the Centre is how the alleged background checks could further stigmatize jury duty. Accepting that the avoidance of jury duty is already well-documented, the Centre notes that prospective background checks will likely lead to further avoidance of jury duty, inevitably resulting in unrepresentative juries.

The Centre concludes, as LEAP did when it reported the story in June, that a full public inquiry is required. This is not an issue that can be swept under the rug. Its lasting effects may, as yet, be unknown – but it is potentially catastrophic to the outcome of past cases decided by vetted jurors. The accountability of police officers and Crown Attorneys who may have engaged in the process is at stake. However, as the Center points out, it is just as important to focus on the victims as it is to focus on the perpetrators. Jurors have potentially had their Charter rights violated, and an investigation into their personal situations is required.

Posted by Ashley Paterson (Law II)

Saturday, September 19, 2009

Quebec Human Rights Commission begins public consultation on racial profiling

This week, the Quebec Human Rights Commission commenced a public consultation on racial profiling. The aim of the consultation is to spark an open dialogue concerning the realities of the systemic problem, specifically among youth aged 14-25 that live in an urban setting. The consultation will seek to inform institutions of the presence of racial profiling, and also to create and implement solutions. The ultimate goal of the Commission is to “…inform and educate the majority, as well as recommending and facilitating the implementation of corrective measures.”

The Commission’s commitments to the public consultation are as follows:

a. The commission will speak openly and constructively about racism with organizations and institutions
b. The Commission will give victims of racial profiling an opportunity to be heard
c. The Commission will give public institutions and community organizations an opportunity to be heard and propose their solutions
d. The commission is committed to continuing its fight against racial profiling.

The consultation process has already begun and will proceed in three phases. Phase 1 will take place in the fall and winter of 2009, and will collect submissions from youth about their racial profiling experiences. Phase 2 will consist of public hearings aimed at developing solutions, as well as the publication of a consultation document developed from the public input. By the end of 2010, Phase 3 will be completed and the Commission will publish its final report with recommendations.

A similar undertaking was conducted by the Ontario Human Rights Commission. Following the public consultation, the Commission released its report Paying The Price: The Human Cost of Racial Profiling.

Posted by Ashley Paterson (Law II)

Tuesday, September 15, 2009

One truth behind wrongful convictions

His supporters call him the world's longest-serving wrongly convicted person. During his 31 years in Ontario prisons, Romeo Phillion’s story, among other things, has highlighted the relevance of police and prosecutorial accountability in wrongful conviction cases.

What specifically did the case highlight? -- a 1986 police report, allegedly suppressed at Phillion’s trial and subsequent appeals showing that Ottawa police investigated and confirmed his alibi.

In 2001, in conjunction with the Osgoode Hall Innocence Project, Association in Defence of the Wrongly Convicted (AIDWYC) lawyers submitted an application to the Minister of Justice under section 696.1 of the Criminal Code on behalf of Romeo Phillion. Phillion spent 31 years in prison for the 1967 stabbing death of Ottawa firefighter Leopold Roy.

In 1972, Phillion was tried, convicted and sentenced to life in prison. There was no physical or circumstantial evidence tying Phillion to the crime. The sole evidence was his recanted confession. Five years after the murder Phillion, unexpectedly, confessed to the stabbing when he was arrested for a robbery. In the last few years, psychiatrists have brought to light the phenomenon of false confessions. In general, false confessions are not always promoted by one’s internal knowledge or actual guilt, but sometimes motivated by external forces, such as duress, diminished capacity, and a misunderstanding of the situation.

On March 5th, 2009, in a 2-1 judgment, the Ontario Court of Appeal quashed Phillion’s conviction for the 1967 murder saying an undisclosed police report that appeared to provide Phillion with an alibi could have left jurors with reasonable doubt regarding his guilt. The report, which came to light in 1998, when Phillion was still in prison, confirmed Phillion was at a Trenton gas station 150 miles away with a broken down car just hours before the murder. Ottawa Detective John McCombie, who prepared the 1968 report, told the Appeal Court last year that he discovered the information which contradicted evidence Phillion was at the gas station. However, no police occurrence report or other evidence exists to corroborate McCombie’s claims.

While the report was not required to be provided to the defence under disclosure practices in place in 1972, when Phillion was tried, "the interests of justice" today require that it be admitted into evidence, the court said. "I find it virtually inconceivable that ... (Crown attorney Malcolm) Lindsay and Ottawa police officers involved in the investigation would have participated in prosecuting the appellant for the Roy murder knowing that he was innocent of the crime," Justice Michael Moldaver said.

The Ontario Court of Appeal overturned his conviction earlier this year, after his lawyers argued that the additional evidence might have led to his acquittal. The Court of Appeal stopped short of entering an acquittal, choosing, instead, to order a new trial. The court’s ruling left the decision on how to proceed in the hands of the Crown. In July, the Attorney General decided to withdraw the charges. Phillion’s lawyers, however, want an outright acquittal.

Last month, as reported by the Ottawa Citizen, Phillon’s lawyers made an application to an Ottawa court seeking to have their client arraigned for murder in attempt to deny the Attorney General the ability to quietly withdraw the charge. Instead, they want to Phillion to be indicted, allowing him to plead not guilty.

The application is expected to be heard by Superior Court Justice Lynn Ratushny in early February of 2011.

Posted by Andrea Anderson (Windsor Law 2009)

Tuesday, August 25, 2009

Canadian Mental Health Association recommends special training for officers armed with tasers

The Saskatchewan division of the Canadian Mental Health Association (CMHA) has recommended that police officers receive special training on how to deal with mentally ill people and that those skills are implemented before administering a Taser.

The brief from the CMHA comes after the Saskatchewan Police Commission, like many others across Canada, has begun to review how Tasers are used by their employees. Specifically, the Commission is reviewing whether they will allow their front-line municipal officers to carry Tasers. The CMHA recommends a “combination of effective and appropriate training and policy changes for the use of conducted energy devices,” that “crisis intervention training be incorporated in police recruit training and that there be ongoing training for all officers,” and that “an independent investigation be launched into the long-term health consequences for people who are stunned by CEDs.”

The use of CEDs is of particular concern to Canadian citizens as a result of the many high-profile cases that have resulted from their questionably improper administration. But what the CMHA’s brief should symbolize is the extreme importance of proper training for police officers in dealing with those that are mentally ill under all circumstances. Just three months ago, LEAP reported on a Newfoundland story where police mistook an autistic boy for a drunk, and threw him in the local lockup overnight.

Posted by Ashley Paterson (Law II)

Thursday, August 13, 2009

RCMP rejects CPC's recommendation that internal RCMP investigations cease in cases involving death

On Tuesday, the Commission for Public Complaints against the RCMP (CPC) released a report concluding that the RCMP’s internal investigation process is inadequate. Referring to the RCMP’s current process as “Police investigating Police,” the CPC concluded that such practice “does not engender confidence in the transparency and integrity of an investigation and its outcomes.” Further, the research done by the CPC revealed some troubling statistics. First, that 25% of investigators knew the member they were investigating. CPC Chair Paul Kennedy noted that this can result in bias, or in situations where the investigating member is of a lower rank than the member being investigated, intimidation. The report also revealed that internal investigations are conducted by members with significantly different levels of experience and qualification.

The CPC made several recommendations to help remedy the internal investigation process until a more permanent solution is created. Among these recommendations were that all member investigations involving death be referred to an external police force or provincial body. The CPC rejected the current RCMP policy that internal investigations be handled like any other investigation because “[p]olice are held to higher account by the very nature of the work they do.”

The response from RCMP Commissioner William Elliot that it was business as usual was very disappointing and likely did little to satisfy the public anticipation that the CPC's recommendations would be implemented. Elliot argued that there are specific situations where it is impossible for the RCMP not to investigate itself, for example, in remote communities where waiting for outside police forces to arrive and begin an investigation could threaten the credibility of forensic evidence. Elliot seemed to believe the investigative process within the RCMP was not as flawed as the CPC found.

Yet to a scrutinizing public eye, or perhaps the families of people such as Robert Dziekanski or Ian Bush who were killed at the hands of RCMP officers, Elliot’s underwhelming response may not be enough. Unfortunately, his response may actually contribute to a lack of transparency and accountability within the RCMP, which implementation of the recommendations was meant to restore. Further, offering exceptional situations where it may be difficult to implement the recommendations (such as in extremely remote communities) appears to be an excuse as to why the recommendations will not work. In short, Elliot has done nothing to restore public confidence regarding internal RCMP investigations, if anything, he has made the situation worse by attempting to protect a method that is clearly flawed.

Posted by Ashley Paterson (LAW II) (LEAP Summer Intern)

Friday, July 24, 2009

Braidwood Inquiry releases Phase 1 report on use of tasers

The long-awaited Phase 1 of the Braidwood Report was publicly released this week, by the Braidwood Commission on Conducted Energy Use, entitled Restoring Public Confidence: Restricting the Use of Conducted Energy Weapons in British Columbia. The report was commissioned as a response to the death of Robert Dziekanski, who died minutes after a RCMP officer shocked him with a conducted energy weapon (CEW), commonly referred to as a Taser, at the Vancouver International Airport. The Braidwood Commission was created to inquire into and report on how CEWs are deployed by those law enforcement agents that use them.

The first part of the report makes 19 recommendations. Braidwood notes that when making recommendations he was guided by several principles – "that the police are subject to civilian authority, that the police must be given appropriate tools to do their job, that the police should use the least force necessary to manage the risk, and that the use of force must be proportionate to the seriousness of the situation." The recommendations in the report can be summarized as follows:

-that CEWs be used only to enforce federal criminal laws;
-that CEWs are not used unless the subject is causing bodily harm or will imminently do so and that no lesser force option can prevent risk of such harm;
-that a curriculum for crisis intervention training be approved and implemented, and that when dealing with emotionally disturbed people officers use de-escalation techniques before using a CEW;
-that an electrical current is not deployed from a CEW for longer than 5 seconds unless the officer believes that a 5-second discharge was not effective in eliminating the risk of bodily harm;
-that paramedic assistance be requested in every medically high-risk situation;
-that if an officer has a CEW they also have an automated defibrillator readily available and that province-wide standards are set in relation to CEWs;
-that the Police Academy be responsible for training officers in the use of CEWs;
-that CEWs be added to the list of restricted products under the Hazardous Products Act and that regulations are created prescribing the circumstances under which CEWs may be imported in, and sold in, Canada;
-that every CEW in use be periodically tested and that if a serious death or injury occurs when a CEW has been used that the weapon be withdrawn from service and its electrical output tested;
-that there be an incident report form to be completed whenever a CEW is used;

-that a CEW research program be created, as well as a special committee established, to review the use of CEWs three years after this report is made public, and
-that as of 2012, the RCMP must abide by the rules, policies and procedures of CEW use that are applicable to provincially regulated law enforcement agencies.

The B.C. government stated yesterday that they accept the recommendations and will undertake implementation of them immediately.

Posted by Ashley Paterson (Law II) (LEAP Summer Intern)

Wednesday, July 22, 2009

The Gates Arrest: Was He The Victim of Racial Profiling?

The New York Times has assembled an impressive line-up of academics to address this question along with the broader issue of race and policing.

They include:
To view the dialogue, click here.

For more information on the arrest of Professor Gates of Harvard University, click here.

Tuesday, July 21, 2009

African American Harvard Professor arrested trying to enter his house

Last Thursday, July 17, 2009, Henry Louis Gates Jr., an African-American Professor at Harvard University, was arrested for disorderly conduct on the steps of his own home. At the scene, Gates accused police officers of being racist.

Prior to his arrest, Gates was returning from a trip which had kept him away from his home for most of the summer. After finding that his door was jammed, he attempted to force it open. Reportedly, a neighbour called the police when she saw a man trying to pry the front door of [Gates’] house open with his shoulder.

According to the police report, Gates proceeded to have an altercation with police. He allegedly shouted at them “[t]his is what happens to black men in America,” “[y]ou don’t know who you're messing with” and that the officers were racist. The officers allege that Gates continued to shout when they tried to identify themselves.

But Charles Ogletree, a Harvard Law Professor who is working as Gates’ lawyer, tells a different story. Ogletree alleges that Gates was cooperative, quickly providing identification to the officers that proved he lived in the home. Conversely, Ogletree says that when Gates requested the badge numbers of the officers involved, they refused to provide them. According to Ogletree Gates asked the officers “[w]hy are you doing this? Is it because I’m a black man and you’re a white officer? I don’t understand why you don’t believe this is my house.” Ogletree also asserts that there was no warning of arrest; while the officers allege that they warned Gates several times that his behaviour was disorderly.

The event is even more surprising considering that Gates is a well-known figure in the community. After completing his undergraduate studies at Yale, Gates also attained a M.A. and Ph.D from the University of Cambridge. For 15 years he was the Chair of the Department of African and African-American studies. He has been named one of Time magazine’s “25 Most Influential Americans.” Further, he is among a small group of approximately 20 Harvard faculty members honoured with University Professorships, awarded for “academic achievements that cross disciplinary boundaries.”

The Harvard Crimson reported this afternoon that the District Attorney’s office has agreed not to pursue the case. Although this seems to be an amicable way to placate an ugly situation, in many ways it is too little too late. Gates has already suffered the humiliation of being arrested on the front porch of his home for simply trying to open his own door. He has already experienced what it feels like to be treated differently because of the colour of his skin. Thus, whether or not the charges are dropped, the damage is done.

Posted by Ashley Paterson (Law II) (LEAP Summer Intern)

Thursday, July 16, 2009

Racial profiling complaints by Halifax Police Service officers against their force filed in Nova Scotia

According to a CBC story published in early June, Constable Charles Bruce of the Halifax Police Service has filed a complaint against the HRP alleging racial discrimination. It is the third such complaint filed within the last year. Const. Bruce alleges that he was not considered for promotion and transfer because of his skin colour. He also alleges that systemic racism within the force is a continuing problem.

Const. Bruce’s complaint arrives on the heels of similar complaints filed against the HRP by Sgt. Robyn Atwell and former police officer Lewis Cain in December 2008. Further, such incidents of internal racial discrimination do not seem to be isolated. Halifax Regional Municipality is currently dealing with several racial discrimination complaints filed by black firefighters with Halifax Fire Services.

The complaints of the three officers with the HRP are detailed on a website that has been developed to draw attention to these issues, http://halifaxregionalpoliceracediscrimination.com/index.htm. Robyn Atwell, HRP’s first black female Sergeant, claims that she has experienced racism since first becoming a member of the force in 2003. Atwell alleges that she has had a knife pulled on her by a member of the force. Cain, the other officer who has filed a complaint, was terminated just 15 months after he was hired due to what he alleges was racial discrimination by both higher ranking officers and his supervisor.

The three officers are represented by Rocky Jones, a prominent lawyer in Nova Scotia who has represented several complaints involving racial discrimination, perhaps the most well known of which is R. v. S.(R.D.).

Posted by Ashley Paterson (Law II) (LEAP Summer Intern)

Saturday, July 4, 2009

Racial profiling in Paris

A recent report entitled Profiling Minorities: A Study of Stop-And-Search Practices in Paris has been released by the Open Society Justice Initiative. The report details a study which began in 2007. It sough to investigate whether law enforcement officers were stopping individuals because of their appearance, or engaging in “ethnic profiling.” The results of the study revealed that police stops and identity checks in Paris are not based on the behaviour of the stopped individual, but most often based on their appearance. Ethnic minorities were stopped by police at a considerably more significant rate than those not perceived to be ethnic minorities.

The report states that “[i]n targeting certain persons because of what they look like and not because of what they have done, law enforcement officers justify and perpetuate ethnic stereotypes.” The report also discussed the negative way in which this reflects on the accountability and transparency of law enforcement officers, “decreasing their effectiveness in preventing and detecting crime.”

The report made several recommendations. To political and legal authorities, it recommended that they acknowledge the problem of ethnic profiling, encourage and fund ethnic profiling research, review legal standards, modify areas of the Code of Criminal procedure and maintain and support specialized police oversight bodies. To French law enforcement authorities, the report recommended, among other things, that officers be required to explain why they are stopping those they stop, to regularly analyze stop records, to make public statistical data on identity checks, stops and searches and to introduce tools to receive public feedback regarding the quality of police services.

Posted by Ashley Paterson (Law II) (LEAP Summer Intern)

Friday, June 26, 2009

Racial profiling in Toronto's Bridle Path

Phipps v. Toronto Police Services Board released last week marks the second positive finding of racial profiling by the Ontario Human Rights Tribunal.

Phipps, a Canada Post mail carrier, was delivering mail on March 9, 2005 in the Bridle Path neighbourhood in Toronto. It is Toronto's most affluent neighbourhood. It was only his second day on the route. He was wearing his Canada Post uniform. Michael Shaw, a police constable who had patrolled the area for years, and Diane Noto had been asked to patrol the area for suspects described as Male, White and Eastern European, who were using a vehicle.

Shaw noticed that Phipps was engaged in what he believed to be “unusual activity,” namely, travelling back and forth across the street. Shaw also noticed that he was not the usual postal worker and was not delivering mail at every house. The officers observed Phipps knocking on a door, speaking with the woman that answered, but apparently not delivering anything. After inquiring with the resident, the officers learned that Phipps had advised her that he had misdelivered something, which Shaw found suspicious. The officers subsequently stopped Phipps who provided identification which, after a check, revealed nothing. They released him. Soon after, the officers encountered another mail carrier and inquired about Phipps, and the carrier confirmed that Phipps was a temporary carrier in the area.

And so, because of stereotypical assumptions about African Canadians, Phipps was not only constructed as a suspect but his explanation and official uniform did not satisfy the police that he was not a criminal.

Phipps later hailed the police officers and asked why they had stopped him. Phipps believed that the officers stopped him because of his skin colour, and noted that a white male delivering water in the area had not been stopped, nor were any white construction workers questioned.

In her reasoning, the adjudicator noted 5 principles that that apply in cases where racial profiling is alleged:

"1. The prohibited ground or grounds of discrimination need not be the sole or the major factor leading to the discriminatory conduct; it is sufficient if they are a factor;
2. There is no need to establish an intention or motivation to discriminate; the focus of the enquiry is on the effect of the respondent's actions on the complainant;
3. The prohibited ground or grounds need not be the cause of the respondent's discriminatory conduct; it is sufficient if they are a factor or operative element;
4. There need be no direct evidence of discrimination; discrimination will more often be proven by circumstantial evidence and inference; and
5. Racial stereotyping will usually be the result of subtle unconscious beliefs, biases and prejudices."

Based on these factors and the circumstantial evidence, Joachim found that on a balance of probabilities, he was the victim of racial profiling. Her reasons include the following observations:
"[23] In my view, the above chronology, as described by the respondent Shaw is more consistent with a finding that the applicant’s skin colour played a role in his actions than the applicant’s alleged unusual activity.
[24] First, the fact that the applicant was not the usual letter White male letter carrier is surely not a suspicious circumstance. Letter carriers take vacation, retire, and/or switch routes, so the fact that another letter carrier was delivering the mail on that particular day cannot explain Constable Shaw’s heightened alertness. I find significant that he did not respond in a similar way to an unfamiliar White male delivering water in the area.
[25] Second, Constable Noto testified that immediately upon turning onto Vernham Avenue, Constable Shaw pointed out the applicant as a person of note. It is not likely that Constable Shaw had already noticed the applicant’s alleged crossing back and forth across the street in an unusual manner as soon as they turned the corner. Whether or not Constables Shaw and Noto noticed a figure in the distance when they turned onto Vernham Avenue, I do not accept their evidence that the figure was crossing back and forth across the street in an unusual manner.
[26] Third, it is not in keeping with the preponderance of probabilities that the applicant was constantly crossing back and forth across the street. The applicant could not recall whether or how often he crossed the street that day. However, he testified and his evidence is in keeping with the preponderance of probabilities that while letter carriers usually deliver their mail on one side of the street and then the other, if they make a mistake in preparing their mail they might cross the street mid-street, occasionally. Since there is no dispute that the applicant was, in fact, a legitimate letter carrier, either he made an unusual number of mistakes and crossed the street an extraordinary number of times on that day, or in the usual manner of letter carriers, he may have crossed the street once or at most twice. I do not accept Constable Shaw’s evidence as in keeping with the preponderance of probabilities that the applicant was crossing the street back and forth in an unusual fashion.
[27] Fourth, Constable Shaw in his original response to the complaint, his will say statement and his evidence at the hearing, noted the fact that the applicant did not stop at every house as an unusual circumstance. However, the evidence of the applicant and Mr. Finlay was that it is not unusual for a letter carrier to skip houses if there is no mail to be delivered and the householder has asked not to have flyers delivered. Indeed, Constable Shaw conceded in cross examination by the applicant that he had in the past seen letter carriers skip houses. In my view, it is in keeping with the preponderance of probabilities that Constable Shaw was well aware that letter carriers do not stop at every house.
[28] Accordingly, I conclude that it was not unusual behaviour on the applicant’s part that caused Constable Shaw to decide to place the applicant under surveillance but rather the fact that he was an African Canadian male in an affluent neighbourhood. His suspicions were not alleviated by the Canada Post uniform, mailbag or mail delivery. It is also noteworthy that the Directed Patrol Assignment related to suspicious persons in the neighbourhood with entirely different characteristics: White, Eastern European, using a vehicle. The fact that it was an African Canadian male without a vehicle that attracted Constable Shaw’s attention is what is unusual."

This case comes more than two years after a finding a racial profiling by the same adjudicator in the case of Nassiah v. Peel (Regional Municipality) Services Board. In that case, the applicant was accused of stealing a bra from Sears. Joachim concluded that Officer Elkington of Peel Regional Police Services consciously or unconsciously discriminated against Ms. Nassiah on the basis of race. Ms. Nassiah was detained for almost 2 hours based on shaky video footage, verbally abused by the officer with regards to her race, prohibited from calling anyone but a lawyer, and humiliated when she actually committed no crime at all.

Posted by Ashley Paterson (Law II) (LEAP Summer Intern)

Saturday, June 20, 2009

Committee on Public Safety and National Security report urges government to create independent national security review body

This month, the Standing Committee on Public Safety and National Security issued its "Review of the Findings and Recommendations Arising From the Iacobucci and O'Connor Inquiries." These inquiries exposed that Mahar Arar, Abdullah Almalki, Ahmad Abou-Elmaati and Muayyed Narreddin were victims of "inaccurate intelligence sharing practices by Canadian security agencies..." The inquiries also "...exposed the glaring lack of civilian oversight of our national security activities." The report begins with the recognition that in the wake of 9/11, anti-terrorism efforts have "resulted in the racial profiling of members of the Muslim and Arab communities ..."

In its report, the Committee expressed strong concerns that all of the O'Connor recommendations had not been implemented, particularly, those concerning oversight. It issued the following five recommendations:

RECOMMENDATION 1:
The Committee reiterates the recommendation made in its report presented to the House of Commons on January 30, 20071 and recommends that the Government of Canada recognize the urgency of the situation by immediately implementing all the recommendations from the Commission of Inquiry into the Actions of Canadian Officials in Relation to Maher Arar.

RECOMMENDATION 2:
The Committee recommends that the Government of Canada immediately issue regular public reports on the progress made in implementing the findings and recommendations arising from the Commission of Inquiry into the Actions of Canadian Officials in Relation to Maher Arar and the Internal Inquiry into the Actions of Canadian Officials in Relation to Abdullah Almalki,
Ahmad Abou-Elmaati and Muayyed Nureddin.

RECOMMENDATION 3:
In consideration of the harm done to Mr. Almalki, Mr. Abou-Elmaati and Mr. Nureddin, the Committee recommends:

• That the Government of Canada apologize officially to Mr. Abdullah Almalki, Mr. Ahmad Abbou-Elmaati and Mr. Muayyed Nureddin.

• That the Government of Canada allow for compensation to be paid to Mr. Almalki, Mr. Abou-Elmaati and Mr. Nureddin as reparation for the suffering they endured and the difficulties
they encountered.

• That the Government of Canada do everything necessary to correct misinformation that may exist in records administered by national security agencies in Canada or abroad with respect to Mr. Almalki, Mr. Abou-Elmaati and Mr. Nureddin and members of their families.

RECOMMENDATION 4:
The Committee recommends that the Government of Canada issue a clear ministerial directive against torture and the use of information obtained from torture for all departments and agencies responsible for national security. The ministerial directive must clearly state that
the exchange of information with countries is prohibited when there is a credible risk that it could lead, or contribute, to the use of torture.

RECOMMENDATION 5:
The Committee recommends, once again, that Bill C-81, introduced in the 38th Parliament, An Act to Establish the National Security Committee of Parliamentarians, or a variation of it, be introduced in Parliament at the earliest opportunity.

Posted by Ashley Paterson (Law II) (LEAP Summer Intern)