Wednesday, April 15, 2009

Executive Director of Alberta's Serious Incident Response Team calls for more cilivian involvement

Clifton Purvis, the ED of Alberta's Serious Incident Response Team, the unit that investigates serious instances of police misconduct, has called for more civilian involvement of investigations. As he put it, "my personal vision would see a much greater balance so that we'd have about a 50-50 split between civilian officers and sworn police officers." The current team is composed of 12 investigators --- four civilian and eight officers from the RCMP and Edmonton and Calgary Police Services.

Tuesday, March 24, 2009

Inquest hears state of policing in Aboriginal communities is ‘deplorable’

The recent deaths of two Aboriginal men while in jail has brought the issue of Aboriginal deaths in custody as a form of systemic abuse to the mainstream consciousness - once again. Earlier this month, Commissioner Davies released his report on the inquiry into the, almost decade old, freezing death of Frank Paul. In his report, the Commissioner called for a civilian body to investigate the custodial deaths of citizens. See the discussion of Frank Paul Inquiry in the March 14, 2009 blog entry entitled “Alone and Cold: The Davies Commission Inquiry into the Death of Frank Paul”

By law, an inquest is required when a person dies while in custody. As noted in the Toronto Star article above, the senseless deaths of two young Aboriginal men who were trapped in cells during a jailhouse fire must be acknowledged by addressing the deplorable state of policing in the First Nations community.

After more than three years of waiting for answers, the families of the victims and the community are anxious to finally have an inquest go forward, said Toronto lawyer Julian Falconer, who is representing the family. The two men died in 2006 when fired engulfed the holding facility in Kashechewan First Nations, a fly-in community in northern Ontario.

According to Coroner Counsel Margaret Creal, witnesses are expected to testify that police frantically tried to free the men as smoke filled the building, but fumbled with unlabelled keys and were not successful.

"These are clearly deaths that never had to happen. The state and conditions of detachments in First Nations territories are deplorable,” said Falconer.

The discussion of Aboriginal deaths in custody should be understood in the broader context of the overrepresentation of Aboriginal people in the criminal justice system. The Aboriginality of the person is a significant factor, if not, the dominant factor in leading to their interaction in the criminal justice system and eventual death in custody. Studies, commissions and reports, including the 1991 Royal Commission into Aboriginal Deaths in Custody, have shown that too many of the deaths of Aboriginal people while in custody are as a result of police action or inaction.

While the factors that bring Aboriginal people into contact with the justice system is their disadvantaged and unequal position in wider society, arguably, the most significant contributing factoring leading to the high levels of death of Aboriginal people while in custody is the failure of authorities to exercise a proper duty of care.

The case in Kashechewan First Nations is not in isolation, as Julian Falconer notes in the above inquest, “red flags to governments, both federally and provincially, are on record dating years back yet these deplorable circumstances were allowed to continue."

Andrea Anderson (Windsor Law III)

Monday, March 23, 2009

Canadian Human Rights Commission urges police forces to start collecting data on who and why they stop individuals for investigation

The Canadian Human Rights Commission and Canadian Race Relations Foundation issued a joint statement this week calling for Canadian police and security officials to start documenting who they stop for an investigation including tracking race, age and gender.

The call for such data collection follows the release of report commissioned for the Canadian Human Rights Commission entitled "The Effectiveness of Profiling from a National Security Perspective" which concludes that there is no evidence to support the reliability or moral legitimacy of profiling based on race or other prohibited grounds of discrimination.

The Ontario Human Rights Commission is already on record in support of race-based data collection by any institution or agency where there is evidence of racial profiling or other evidence of racial discrimination. See "Policy and Guidelines on Racism and Racial Discrimination" (Ontario Human Rights Commission, 2003) at 43-48.

Friday, March 20, 2009

The Vancouver Police Department’s new strategy for the Downtown Eastside

The Vancouver Police Department outlined a new change to the way it polices the Downtown Eastside in its board meeting on Wednesday. Under the changed strategy, the VPD will not arrest and charge drug users and expend resources on prosecuting. Rather, they will shift their focus to street disorder. However, the implication of this shift is that it increases the presence of the VPD in the neighbourhood. The business plan identifies a number of behaviours to be targeted by the VPD. These include aggressive panhandling, squeegeeing, open-air drug markets, unlicensed street vending and sleeping in city parks. The 20% increase in the number of public nuisance tickets the police have been handing out to the homeless and other residents in the neighbourhood was not a part of the new plan. However, it is troubling that considerable discretion remains for the police to hand out public nuisance tickets to individuals who have neither a roof over their head or money to pay the fines.

The shift in policy actually seems like a continuation from Project Civil Society, implemented under the former mayor. While David Eby, executive director of the British Columbia Civil Liberties Association, sees these changes as a positive step, he said he would like to see the VPD return items the police have seized from homeless people in recent years. Activists have said that the police strategy in the neighbourhood has been to target homeless people to clean the streets for the 2010 Winter Olympics, view
http://www.2010homelesschampions.ca.

Posted by Mandy Cheema (Law III)

Taser to the head can cause seizures

A new report in the Canadian Medical Association Journal says that a taser deployed to the head can cause seizures. Previously, taser-related incidents concentrated on cardiac problems resulting from shots to the chest. The report discusses a police chase involving an Ontario police officer who was mistakenly tasered, ultimately suffering a seizure. Dr. Richard Wennberg, the senior author of the report, concluded that the taser certainly caused the officer’s seizure, as he had no prior history of seizures or underlying conditions that would precipitate a seizure. Listing seizures as a health risk, the report describes the dangers as follows: “Repetitive stimuli such as flashing lights or electrical stimuli can induce seizures in some individuals. The risk may be heightened if electrical stimuli or current passes through the head region.” Taser International had no comment either with respect to the report or the case involving the police officer.

The report is released in the wake of an incident where the RCMP tasered a distraught teenager this week, see http://www.vancouversun.com/news/Mounties+Taser+teen+said+wanted/1406815/story.html. This week the Toronto Police Service released its taser statistics which revealed that two 15-year-old boys were tasered last year. See "Boys 15, Tasered by police, stats show."

Posted by Mandy Cheema (Law III)

Thursday, March 19, 2009

Asian lawyer wrongly detained at Vancouver International Airport on suspicion of human trafficking

Earlier this week, Dongdong Huang, a well-known lawyer in Vancouver was wrongfully detained and questioned on a business trip to China. He was accused of being involved in human trafficking. His humiliating ordeal began when a security official searched his carry-on bag and discovered a number of Chinese passports. Huang was on his way to China to return the passports, which belonged to his clients. His clients had lost their bid for seasonal work visas in Canada.

This appears to be a classic case of racial profiling where state officials over-react to equivocal conduct and refuse to accept the reasonable explanation offered by the person being questioned. According to the Globe and Mail story linked above, Customs officials "appeared incredulous when he said he was a lawyer."

Tuesday, March 17, 2009

Harper government to cut funding of RCMP police complaints commission

According to estimates tabled by the federal Treasury Board, the RCMP Public Complainants Commission which oversees the RCMP will face a substantial cut in funding from the federal government. Commission chair Paul Kennedy has warned that the cuts will force him to cut a policy division created in 2007 to explore the use of tasers and which was responsible for the creation of the new RCMP policy. See the discussion of the new policy in the February 13, 2009 blog entry entitled "RCMP admit dangers of tasers and establish new policy for use and training." The policy division is currently conducting research on how the police deal with mentally ill suspects.

Monday, March 16, 2009

Aboriginal groups call for inquiry into adequacy of police investigation of more than 83 women who have gone missing in BC


FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE
March 11, 2009

Vancouver – A coalition of aboriginal leaders, community groups and family members released an open letter and a set of demands today calling for a public inquiry into the missing and murdered women of the Downtown Eastside of Vancouver and the Highway of Tears, supports for families enduring the current appeal process, and commencement of the trial for the 20 further alleged victims of Robert William Pickton.

“We feel it is critically important that this inquiry into the police actions, or inaction, on these files takes place now; we should not be forced to wait until all of the appeals are exhausted by the accused,” said Grand Chief Stewart Phillip of the Union of B.C. Indian Chiefs. “Truth, accountability, reform and reconciliation measures relative to this continuing horrific tragedy are all part of what the families of the victims and our Aboriginal communities need to see.”

The open letter says that the Provincial Government should not wait for William Pickton to exhaust his appeal routes, and should call an inquiry into the policing and government failings surrounding the murdered and missing women. Pickton’s appeal will be heard for two weeks starting March 30, 2009. The letter also calls for the Inquiry to examine the cases of the missing and murdered women along the “Highway of Tears”, also known as Highway 16 between Prince George and Prince Rupert in northern British Columbia.

“Our community sees what’s happening along Highway 16 as exactly what happened in Vancouver’s Downtown Eastside,” says David Dennis, President of the United Native Nations, an organization that represents off-reserve aboriginal people. “We can’t have this tragedy of ignoring these disappearing and murdered women repeat itself – we need to break this cycle.”

The letter was sent on Wednesday morning to the Attorney General of B.C., the Solicitor General of B.C. and the Premier of British Columbia.

MEDIA CONTACTS
Stewart Phillip, Grand Chief, UBCIC – 250-490-5314
Robert Holmes, President, BCCLA – 604-681-1310
David Dennis, President, UNN - (604) 868-4283

Saturday, March 14, 2009

Alone and Cold: The Davies Commission Inquiry into the Death of Frank Paul

Ten years in the making, in a 445 page report, Commissioner William Davies, a retired judge, gave a scathing account of the circumstances that led to the death of Frank Paul. Frank Paul, a Mi’kmaq man, succumbed to hypothermia after being dumped into an alley. Earlier on that night, he had been placed in a holding cell by the Vancouver Police Department.

In his report, “Alone and Cold: The Davies Commission Inquiry into the Death of Frank Paul,” Commissioner Davies criticizes both police conduct on the night of December 5, 1998 and the VPD investigation that followed. Citing the inadequacies of the police investigation as being “methodically flawed,” he noted that the investigating officer did not contact several key witnesses. He further stated that the systemic flaws in the investigation procedures of the VPD are so severe that it is not feasible for even external police investigating the VPD. Finally, in a recommendation that has been gaining popularity in British Columbia, he stated that a civilian body should be established to investigate the custodial deaths of civilians. The recommendations relating to police investigations are directed towards the province’s 11 municipal police forces that police roughly 30% of the population, while the RCMP police 1/3 of the province.

What are significant are his findings on death in police custody, an issue that has garnered much attention in recent years. Commissioner Davies recommended a broader interpretation of what constitutes a death in police custody. Davies stated that “a death in a police department jail cell, a death resulting from an officer’s use of force or motor vehicle, or a death arising from some other form of police interaction with the deceased.” While circumstances of police custody deaths will not be limited to the foregoing, the Commissioner has recommended for an expansive framework to the circumstances, situations and police actions that result in the custodial deaths of civilians.

The Commissioner looked at the actions of other public bodies as well. During the inquiry, the Commissioner had argued that he had the jurisdiction to inquire into the reasons the Criminal Justice Branch of the Ministry of Attorney General did not advance criminal charges against any of the involved police officers. The British Columbia Supreme Court held that the Commission could hear this evidence from the Crown. However, the Criminal Justice Branch appealed this decision and is currently on reserve with the BC Court of Appeal.

The BC Coroners Service was criticized for failing to inform the family of his death and for failing to keep an accurate and complete record of his death, citing it initially as a hit and run, rather than a death in police custody. Also, cognizant of Mr. Paul’s personal circumstances, Davies recommended the establishment of a civilian run alcoholic treatment program for chronic homeless alcoholics.

Posted by Mandy Cheema (Windsor Law III)

Sunday, March 8, 2009

BC government introduces legislation to amend police complaints process

Last week, the British Columbia Legislature introduced Bill 6 -- Police (Misconduct, Complaints, Investigations, Discipline and Proceedings) Amendment Act, 2009. Solicitor-General John van Dongen stated that the legislation is intended to give effect to the recommendations of Justice Josiah Wood who prepared a 2007 report on the BC complaints process. Some of the changes include:

"— Making it mandatory for external police forces to investigate any in-custody death or serious injury.

— Empowering the complaints commissioner, not the police force facing allegations, to decide how to proceed with a complaint.

— Allowing the commissioner to track all investigations in real time.

— Compelling police officers to provide statements within five days of a request.

— Increasing the maximum-allowable suspension for misconduct to 30 days from five."

Posted by Professor Tanovich

Toronto lawyer calls for all police-civilian interactions to be videotaped

Peter Biro, a lawyer with Weir Foulds in Toronto who has represented many clients who have sued the police, has called for all police interactions with civilians to be videotaped.

Tuesday, March 3, 2009

RCMP report warns officers of threat posed by modern technology

It has just been made public that the BC RCMP has warned its officers that modern technology could prove to be a vice. In a report written approximately one month before the Dziekanski death, RCMP officers were warned that phone cameras and You Tube could make them especially vulnerable to public scrutiny of their actions. It further stated that recordings of police activities could lead to "increasingly more public exposure of RCMP member actions that some may perceive to be inappropriate." The BC RCMP has not commented on whether this report was the result of any RCMP-related incident.

Posted by Mandy Cheema (Windsor Law III)

Sunday, March 1, 2009

A rare glimpse into one man's attempts to seek redress for racial profiling through the Ontario police complaints process

In his story "Riding while black, or looking for trouble?", Toronto Star reporter Jim Rankin chronicles the numerous incidents that Arden Ditten, a Black Toronto resident, has had with the Toronto Police Service over the past five years. It also reveals the flaws of a police complaints process that allows the police to investigate themselves particularly on issues that they often fail to properly understand such as racial profiling.

Posted by Professor Tanovich

Thursday, February 26, 2009

Toronto Police Service to participate in study of racial profiling

In a precedent setting step, the Toronto Police Service have agreed to participate in an American study of policing to be conducted by the Consortium for Police Leadership in Equity by providing the research group with data on race.

What remains uncertain is what race data the police will share. The problem with arrest data is that it only shows who is arrested not who comes into contact with the police. Hopefully, it will be contact cards and use of force data that is released. It is this data that will reveal the scope of over-policing of racialized groups in Toronto.

To date, the only police service in Canada to officially collect race data on police stops is the Kingston Police Service despite repeated calls by academics and the Ontario Human Rights Commission. The KPS launched a one-year pilot project in 2003. The Kingston experience is summarized in an article by its former Chief, Bill Closs, and Paul McKenna -- "Profiling a Problem in Canadian Police Leadership: the Kingston Police Data Collection Project" (2008), 49 Canadian Public Administration 143.

This is another significant step take by the Toronto Police Service to address the problem of racial profiling. In 2007, the TPS and the Ontario Human Rights Commission signed a Charter Project document which "formalized a three-year collaborative approach to human rights and anti-racism perspectives in all policing activities." In July, 2008, the first Annual Status Report of the Charter was published.

Posted by Professor Tanovich

Wednesday, February 25, 2009

Braidwood Inquiry begins hearing testimony from the four RCMP Constables involved in the Robert Dziekanski taser death

As I write this post, the Braidwood Inquiry is hearing from RCMP Constable Gerry Rundel, one of the four RCMP officers involved in Robert Dziekanski's death. I am here on my law school reading week. This is a remarkable experience which has made it astonishingly clear to me the legislative reforms needed to ensure accountability from police officers.

On the possible role race played

On the first day of Rundel's testimony, Zofia Cisowski, could not bear to watch the video of her son’s final moments and ended up leaving and not returning. Constable Rundel described his initial response to the RCMP dispatch he received shortly before arriving at Vancouver International Airport. What is most troubling is the way the dispatcher described Mr. Dziekanski -- “a non-white male with dark hair wearing a white jacket.” What role did race play in the manner in which the RCMP responded? Was it routine to have four constables arrive separately in their police cruisers? Is it plausible to assume that the RCMP response was influenced, in part, by the moral panic that has gripped airports since 9/11 with its impact felt most prominently by those who loook Arab or Muslim? Constable Rundel did not testify as to whether the description by the dispatcher was communicated amongst the four RCMP officers before or when they converged at the airport.

Whether the description of “non-white male with dark hair” influenced their reaction remains to be seen. Although Commission Counsel raised this possibility, he did so subtly and did not make the link between what role, if any, race played that day at the airport. However, in raising that query, Commission Counsel introduced the possibility for that conclusion to be drawn.

On Constable Rundel’s justification

Perhaps what is even more astonishing is Constable Rundel’s justification for the taser. On numerous occasions, he repeatedly said that he feared for his safety. The cause of this fear? A stapler. It is difficult to believe that an RCMP officer (wearing a bullet-proof vest), trained and fully equipped with various tools, such as a baton, pepper spray, taser and firearm (not to mention the superb physical fitness of most police officers), would be afraid of a stapler- especially in the company of three equally equipped and trained RCMP officers. Surely, wearing a bullet-proof vest would ward off attacks by a stapler.

On the RCMP’s inconsistent position

Prior to Constable Rundel’s testimony, the RCMP maintained that Mr. Dziekanski made combative gestures holding the stapler before the taser was deployed. Constable Rundel further testified that Mr. Dziekanski was demonstrating “non-compliant” behaviour in raising his hands and not complying with RCMP orders. However, the video evidence does not show him raising his hands before the taser is deployed. The decision to taser was made within 4 seconds upon arriving and within thirty seconds, he was tasered five times. During this time, very little was done during the intervals to back off and give Mr. Dziekanski a chance to respond, nor was an effort made during this time to assess his medical situation. Moreover, Walter Kosteckyj’s questioning made it clear that Mr. Dziekanski had only raised his arms after being tasered- in all likelihood, as a natural response to the electric shock waves being sent through his body.

Constable Rundel admitted that Robert Dziekanski may have been frightened and felt trapped when the four RCMP officers surrounded him that day. Upon further questioning, he said there was no time to give Dziekanski a warning before the taser was deployed and admitted no attempt was made to find out where he was from or where he was going. However, he did not back down from maintaining that he and his colleagues acted properly.

On the language barrier

In response to Commission Counsel’s question as to whether the language barrier may have complicated communications, Constable Rundel did not acknowledge the possibility of a language barrier of a Polish immigrant coming to Canada for the very first time. For more on language barriers and law enforcement practices, see Vera Institute of Justice.

For up-to-date information visit the Braidwood Inquiry website.

Posted by Mandy Cheema (Windsor Law III)

Police associations call for all officers to be armed with tasers

The Canadian Police Association (CPA) and the Canadian Association of Chiefs of Police (CACP), the two largest police organizations in the country, have released a position document advocating greater use of tasers or conducted energy devices. According to CPA President, Charles Momy, tasers not only save lives but do not cause death. Tom Kaye, Vice-President of the CACP, stated that "we reiterate that to date, there is no evidence, either scientific or medical, that a conducted-energy weapon has been the direct cause of death anywhere, at any time, on any person." According to their position document, conducted energy devices should be restricted to situations of "active resistance" or where there are threats to officer and public safety.

The Globe and Mail responded with a scathing editorial "Dangerously Blank Slates." As it observes "...these words are merely a blank slate on which police may write almost any self-justification they wish. They give police a licence for the use of massive force, even where, as in [the Dziekanski case] it is unjustifiable."

On the issue of the dangers posed by tasers, we need a national debate informed by independent research free of any links to Taser International. While the CPA and CACP contend that studies reveal that tasers are safe, there are contrary studies. For example, a study conducted by Amnesty International found that tasers were a cause or contributing cause in the death of 67 individuals. See "Less than Lethal? The Use of Stun Guns in US Law Enforcement". See further, research by Dr. Andrew Dennis, of the Cook County Hospital Trauma Unit and a former police officer. Finally, there is a study by University of California cardiologists recently published in the American Journal of Cardiology entitled "Relation of Taser (Electrical Stun Gun) Deployment to Increase in In-Custody Sudden Deaths."

Posted by Mandy Cheema (Windsor Law III)

Monday, February 23, 2009

Almost 1/3 of police charges get withdrawn or dismissed

According to recently released data by Statistics Canada on our adult criminal justice system, approximately 30% of charges laid by the police in 2006-2007 were either withdrawn by the Crown or dismissed or stayed by the courts.

Why is this happening? What role does race play? If a disproportionate number of these cases involve racialized individuals, then it would provide additional evidence of the scope of racial profiling. There is already some evidence that this is the case. In their 2008 series, Crime and Punishment, the Toronto Star uncovered data that reveals that racialized individuals are 53 percent more likely than Whites to be not convicted. No conviction is defined as (i) an acquittal; (ii) a withdrawal or stay of charges; and, (iii) a finding of guilt with a discharge on sentencing. See Rankin and Powell, "Is Justice System Blind to Colour" Toronto Star (21 July 2008).

One remedy is to have Crown Attorneys screen arrests before charges are laid. This is the current practice in British Columbia, Quebec and New Brunswick. See the discussion in McGoey, "The 'Good' Criminal Law Barrister: A Crown Perspective" (2004). In New Brunswick, only 16% of the cases were withdrawn or stayed as compared to 40% in Ontario where there is no pre-charge screening. While Ontario and other provinces have mandatory post-charge screening, the concern is the delay in review and timing of withdrawal.

Posted by Professor Tanovich

Friday, February 13, 2009

RCMP admit dangers of tasers and establish new policy for use and training

On February 12, 2009, RCMP Commissioner William Elliot appeared before the Standing Committee on Public Safety and National Security to update them on changes to RCMP taser policies and training following the release of Standing Committee's June 2008 Report.

The RCMP now acknowledge that tasers or Conducted Energy Weapons, as they are now called, can be deadly particularly in cases of "acutely agitated individuals." As a result, enhanced training and policies on use were put into place in June. According to the new policy, tasers can only be used "where it is necessary to do so in circumstances of threats to officer or public safety." In addition, officers are required to report all uses of the taser including cases where it is drawn but not used.

Whether these changes will reduce the use and deaths associated with what Commissioner Elliott refers to as a "useful weapon" remains to be seen. The British Columbia Civil Liberties Association has called for a moratorium on the use of tasers.

It will be interesting to see what impact the changes have on the recommendations that will be produced once the Braidwood Inquiry in Vancouver is completed. The Braidwood Inquiry was established following the death of Robert Dzierkanski at Vancouver's International Airport in October of 2007. Dzierkanski was tasered five times.

Posted by Professor Tanovich and Robert Tarantino

Thursday, February 12, 2009

Ontario Court of Appeal restores custodial sentence for court officer who assaulted a young person in his custody

In R. v. Byrne, 2009 ONCA 134, the Ontario Court of Appeal restored a 90-day custodial sentence for a court officer with the Toronto Police Service who assaulted a teenaged girl whom he was transporting to court. The trial judge had concluded that in addition to a breach of trust, the officer falsely arrested the victim and then colluded with his partner, a trainee officer, to write a false report. He also tried to impede a subsequent police investigation.

The Court of Appeal relied on its earlier decision in R. v. Feeney, [2008] O.J. No. 4464 (C.A.). Feeney involved four court officers with the Toronto Police Service who were convicted of assaulting a prisoner in the cells of Old City Hall courthouse. The officers had viciously assaulted the victim after handcuffing and shackling him because he had spilled his juice on one of the officers. As in Byrne, the officers attempted to cover up what they had done including falsifying reports.

Posted by Professor Tanovich

Toronto Police Service ordered to release data on police stops

In Toronto Police Services Board v. ( Ontario) Information and Privacy Commissioner, 2009 ONCA 20, the Ontario Court of Appeal restored a decision of the Information and Privacy Commissioner of Ontario granting Toronto Star reporter James Rankin access to Toronto Police Service’s data stored on the Criminal Information Processing System (CPIS) and the Master Name Index (MANIX). Rankin wanted the information to follow up on his 2002 series on racial profiling and had applied for access by relying on s. 2(1) of the Municipal Freedom of Information and Protection of Privacy Act, R.S.O. 1990, c. M. 56 (“the Act”). As noted in the judgment "his purpose in seeking the information is to test the Board's claim, in response to an earlier series of articles he wrote, that the Police do not engage in racial profiling."

The Toronto Police argued that they did not need to release the information because it was not a “record” within the meaning of the Act, and that even if it could be deemed a record, that it would be too costly to produce as it would require their staff to create an algorithm in order to free the database of personal identifiers.

The Court rejected these arguments, applying a broad interpretation of s. 2(1) of the Act, in arguing that this “approach – one of presumptive access – reflects the fact that, because municipal institutions function to serve the public, they ought in general to be open to public scrutiny.”

Posted by Laroux Peoples